DO YOU AGREE with 117-111 from Burt Clements & 116-112 from Dave Moretti?

No, I had it for Mayweather by 2 rounds. But 117-111 is a joke

 

Their scorecards were corrupt

 

116-112 was the consesus amongst boxing media

mayweather win was how 82% saw it

12% saw it a draw

6% for maidana

and not one respectable journalist scored it for maidana or a draw

mostly small websites etc scored it for maidana aka people who don't know ****

 

I'll have to watch it again, thought the cards were quite wide on the night. Many rounds were close.

 

I actually agree with Moretti, he had my same exact score card. I don't agree with the 117-111, that is way too wide IMO.

 

116-112 i think could be fair but i didnt see that fight that way. 117-111 is a damn joke and needs to be fired

 

mayweather won 7 rds clearly

maidana won 2 rounds clearly

3 rounds were debatable

from what i remember...

*edit*

found my scorecard

mayweather won, 2,6,7,9,10,11,12

maidana won, 1,5

close rounds, 3,4,8

 

Anything from 115-113 to 116-112.

A Draw is bad scoring.

And 7-5 for Maidana is attrocious

 

115-113 Floyd with couple of swing rounds so could have gone either way.

 

Total garbage. Madaina won the first 5 rounds, 8 and 12. Hands down. not even debatable really.

 

Boxing Media Scores

Tim Starks (The Queensberry Rules : 114-114 DRAW**

Scott Christ (Bad Leftt Hook) : 115-113 Mayweather

Barry Jones (Boxnation TV) : 117-111 Mayweather

Steve Lillis (Boxnation TV) : 116-113 Mayweather

John Wharton (KCC Boxing Show) : 114-114 DRAW**

Ron Lewis (The Times) : 116-114 Mayweather

Kevin Iole (Yahoo) : 115-113 Mayweather

Adam Abramowitz (Saturday Night Boxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Chris Mannix (Sports Illustrated) : 116-112 Mayweather

Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 115-113 Mayweather

Mike Coppinger (USA Today) : 115-113 Mayweather

Alex Morris (KTC Boxing) : 114-114 DRAW**

Ramon Aranda (3 More Rounds) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paul Webb (First Class Boxing) : 116-112 Mayweather

Cliff Rold (***********) : 114-114 DRAW**

Shaun Brown (***********) : 115-113 Mayweather

Steve Zemach (Queensberry Rules) : 114-114 DRAW**

Brian Campbell (ESPN) : 115-113 Mayweather

Michael Woods (The Sweet Science) : 117-113 Mayweather

All About Boxing : 114-114 DRAW**

Victor M Salazar (Tha Boxing Voice) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Steve Kim (Maxboxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Corey Quincy (FightersXchange) : 115-113 Mayweather

Asian Boxing : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Al Bernstein (Showtime TV) : 115-114 Mayweather

Steve Farhood (Showtime TV) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paulie Malignaggi (Showtime TV) : 115-114 Mayweather

Boxing Socialist : 115-113 Mayweather

The Heavy Bag : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Danny Winterbottom (Boxing News) : 117-113 Mayweather

Wolfgang Shiffbauer (Sturm Promotions) : 115-113 Mayweather

Paddy Cronan (OnTheGrindBoxing) : 117-111 Mayweather

Danny Flexen (Boxing News) : 116-112 Mayweather

Matt Mojica (The Fight Source) : 115-113 Mayweather

Tris Dixon (Boxing News ED) : 117-112 Mayweather

Phil D Jay (World Boxing News) : 115-113 Mayweather

Steve Bunce (Boxnation TV) : 116-112 Mayweather

Pro Boxing Fans : 116-112 Mayweather

James Tonks (Ringnews 24) : 115-113 Mayweather

Boxing Mad Magazine : 115-113 Mayweather

Stevie J Adams (Boxing Mad Magazine) : 117-112 Mayweather

Nathan Fogg (Boxing News Online): 116-112 Mayweather

The Boxing Advocaat : 116-112 Mayweather

Iconic Boxing : 115-113 Mayweather

Fight Insight : 115-113 Mayweather

Lou Dibella (Promoter) : 116-113 Mayweather

V2 Boxing : 116-113 Mayweather

Daniel Vano (***************) : 115-114 MAIDANA***

The Boxing Channel : 115-113 Mayweather

Check Left : 116-112 MAIDANA***

The Title Fight : 114-114 DRAW**

New Legend Boxing : 115-113 Mayweather

Ray Markarian (The Sweet Science) : 116-113 Mayweather

William Holmes (Boxing Insider) : 116-112 Mayweather

Danny Gonzalez (Tha Boxing Voice) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Joel Sebastianelli (KO Digest) : 116-112 Mayweather

Ryan Bivins (SweetBoxing) : 116-112 Mayweather

Onthebeak Boxing : 115-114 Mayweather

Ring Magazine TV : 118-110 Mayweather

Max Kellerman (HBO TV) : 116-112 Mayweather

Jake Donovan (***********) : 115-113 Mayweather

Nacion Boxeo : 115-113 Mayweather

Josh McDaniel (Leave It The Ring Radio) : 116-113 Mayweather

Write On The Button : 115-113 Mayweather

Kevin McRae (Bleacher Report) : 115-113 Mayweather

Fight Ghost : 115-113 Mayweather

The Cruelest Sport : 116-113 Mayweather

Gareth A Davies (The Telegraph) : 116-113 Mayweather

Tommy Allan (Boxing Asylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Nigel Collins (ESPM FNFs) : 114-114 DRAW**

Ron Borges ( Boston Herald) : 115-114 Mayweather

NY Post : 115-113 Mayweather

The Sweet Science : 116-113 Mayweather

Leave It In The Ring Radio : 115-113 Mayweather

Associated Press : 115-113 Mayweather

ESPN.com : 115-113 Mayweather

Jeff Powell (The Mail) : 117-113 Mayweather

John Hoolan (Freelance) : 114-114 DRAW**

Liam Hoppe (Eurosport) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ben Thompson (Fighthype) : 118-110 Mayweather

UK Fighthype : 117-111 Mayweather

TKO Radio : 115-115 DRAW**

Steve Carp (Las Vegas Review-Journal) : 116-112 Mayweather

S.I.com : 116-112 Mayweather

Ernest Gabion (***********) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

3 More Rounds : 115-113 Mayweather

Mike Sloan (Secondsout) : 117-111 Mayweather

John J Raspanti (Doghouseboxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Anthony Larger (Bad Left Hook) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Kevin Mitchell (The Guardian) : 116-114 Mayweather

Andy Paterson (BoxingAsylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ed Robinson (Sky Sports TV) : 115-113 Mayweather

John Evans (Live Fight) : 116-112 Mayweather

Aaron Richardson (BoxingAsylum) : 115-113 Mayweather

Kasim Aslam (Global Boxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Ciaran Shanks (Irvine Times) : 115-113 Mayweather

Tom Gray (Ring Magazine) : 115-113 Mayweather

Marcos Villegas (The Boxing Channel) : 116-113 Mayweather

Ciaran Gibbons (Freelance) : 117-114 Mayweather

Lee John Wyle (The Sweet Science) : 115-113 Mayweather

Mathew McEvoy (Forever Sports) : 116-113 Mayweather

John A MacDonald (Livefight) : 115-113 Mayweather

Agent One Sports : 115-113 Mayweather

Chris Davies (LCD Boxing) : 115-113 MAIDANA***

Paul Daley (TopClassBoxing) : 115-113 Mayweather

Boxing.com : 114-114 Draw**

Sam Sheppard (Queensberry Rules) : 116-112 Mayweather

Billy Ferguson (UK Fighthype) : 116-112 Mayweather

Ben Weisman (BoxingAsylum) : 116-112 Mayweather

Kieran Mulvaney (ESPN) : 116-112 Mayweather

Andrew McKart (FirstClassBoxing) : 114-114 DRAW*



Damn, nobody thought Maidana won???

 

LOL; apparently it is debatable if EIGHTY TWO PERCENT of boxing writers thought Mayweather won and SIX PERCENT thought he lost.

I've watched the fight three times now;

Rounds 1 and 5 Maidana. Rounds 8 and 12 even, the rest Mayweather.

 

1 and 5 were definitely the only clear maidana rounds....

i could see someone giving 8.....

but 12 was a mayweather round.

 

116-112 is very accurate if you know how to score fights