Sorry for going off topic, but seeing the name "Kid Cincinnati" made me think of this; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEjo0ajod1M
same every time styles make fights............. they can fight 100 times and big george would win them all like ali said ..........
I agree, I don't think it would be a forgone conclusion with a prime Smokin' Joe. Joe was not the same fighter at that point. Size and style it still doesnt bode well for Senor Smoke but I think it is a much different fight.
Frazier was far from his prime, Ken Norton has discussed sparring with Frazier that he was not the same fighter. Watching Frazier post FOTC you see a slower version much less dynamic eye sight.
Foreman is still a nightmare for Frazier. The Frazier of the FOTC and a few fights leading up to that would fare somewhat better, but he would still get stopped.
You need to be fast, mobile, crafty, defensively sound, and have a good right hand to beat Big George. Frazier lacked the big right hand and speed, but he did have his moments.