Fighters whom have never been dropped by a punch in their entire careers. 15+ years

you know who had an underrated hell of a chin? peter manfredo jr

 

Oh wow. You are so full of sh!t. That was obviously a knockdown. The punch caused it. You know it, but you'll never admit it.

 

Those are judgement calls. This isn't the case here. The ref just missed it. Was he hurt? no, but, technically it was a kd. Doesn't take away from him at all though.

 

ya true

 

That knockdown is such a polarizing issue. You have guys who hate Floyd using it as ammo that he has no chin, which isn't true. And then his groupies, who deny it beyond logic. It's really not a big deal even if it was counted.

 

He staggered back as a result of eating a perfect counter hook and touched a glove down to keep his balance. It wasn't called a kd, but it probably should have been. That said, the one official kd called against him wasn't the result of a punch, so it all evens out, I suppose.

 

How bout we only count official kds?

 

I can't believe people are arguing about the Floyd knockdown against Judah...regardless of whether it should've been counted or not, he does have an official knockdown against Carlos Hernandez early in his career when he injured his hand during a punch and had to take a knee. The ref counted that as an official knockdown, so whether it's under lame circumstances or not, Floyd technically has a knockdown in his career.

 

Mayweather was KD'ed by Judah, and officially by Carlos Henandez. There's an argument to be made that Genaro Hernandez KD'ed him as well.

 

If your glove touches after a punch, even if you're off balance prior to the punch, the rules are it's a knockdown. Especially when, as you admit, the punch made him more off balance.

We will never know if the glove would have touched had there not been a punch because there was a punch. Your statement is a fallacy. It would be like me saying, "The world would have ended had I not made this post." We can never know if the world would have ended had I not made the post because I did make the post.

 

Knocked down by Judah and Genaro Hernandez. FMJ needs to get off that list

 

Hernandez didn't really land clean with the double hook that he threw against FMJ in the first, so when Mayweather went down it seemed more like it was due to being off balance. It could have been called, since the punch glanced off the shoulder, but then again, so could have Mayweather's return of the favor that occurred later on in the round. Nady didn't call either incident a kd, though, so whatever.

One official kd against Famaso, though.

 

You know you got a solid chin if you survive the almighty CHECK HOOK

 

You know you're dealing with a ***** if they didn't think that Judah's KD Of Floyd is as legit as it could get.
It was a perfect counter hook to a lunging jab by Floyd.
The only think illegit about it is the ref calling it a slip.