Kell Brook over Shawn Porter because Kell beat a fighter who was juicing whereas Ward won while he was juicing.
Ward gave Froch a Boxing lesson. Brook vs Porter was painful to watch cause of all the holding,clinching,headbutting,rabbit punching etc. Brook can't fight on the inside. Ward is a genious when it comes to Inside fighting, Amir Khan should learn some skills from Andre Ward, he's so lucky he's got the luxury to train with him as Khan sucks on the inside,big time. So I'd choose Ward's win over Froch and rightly so.
I agree, its a shame Ward doesn't fight much often, he's clearly a genius inside the ring. Made Froch look clueless in some rounds.
It's a legitimate question that needs to be asked. Look at all the hype around Brook nowadays, many Brits are making it out to be one of the greatest wins in history.
Ward Froch... Two of the best fighters in the division then Andre basically outclasses & dominates Froch Brook Porter was still a closeish fight.
Ward over Froch, based on the fact that Ward dominated the #2 guy in his division, and what Froch went on to do after that fight.
Froch is one of the better fighters of the last decade/half decade. Porter wasn't one of the better titlists at the time he lost his title.
Porter had some decent wins over Malignaggi and Alexander, but before the Ward fight, Froch had wins over Taylor and Pascal. After losing to Ward, Froch went on to beat Bute, Kessler in a rematch, and Groves.