BETTER WIN: Pacquiao defeating Bradley or Mayweather defeating Maidana twice?

Not anymore...
Hope I'm wrong tho, I like Timmy

 

But people have said that PAC just doesn't have it anymore after that ko loss to Marquez but earlier in his career, PAC had been knocked out in the past to become a 8 division champion and fighter of the decade.

Not bad for a 1 dimensional fighter and a "has been".

 

Funny you take his word on that, but when Floyd said he was fighting flat footed in the first Chino fight "for the fans" you called bull****.

Russian IS NOT better than Chino. Hell naw

 

Well, Bradley did have a lot to prove since he was labelled as a ''runner'' in the first fight winning a unpopular decision against Pac.

He must have had a very bad experience in the boxing community and receiving threats etc.

This fight did just that with Provodnikov, he showed that he is not a ''runner''.. he has heart and even though he was hurt throughout the fight, he still manages to outbox Provodnikov.

Then after the Provodnikov fight, Bradley showed the world that he outboxed a great counter puncher in Marquez.

 

Seems like a thread with an agenda.
In the case mentioned, you would have to say Pacs win is better, but you could go round in silly circles like this all night.
What was better, Floyds win over Oscar when a LMW champ or Pacs when Oscar was struggling with the weight.
What was better Floyds win over Marquez when he came in over the agreed weight and before Marquez was a fully fledged WW or Pacs win over Marquez where he struggled.
What was better Pacs win over Cotto at a catchweight or Floyds over Cotto which wasnt.

It could go on and Im sure different answers from different posters would be given

 

Pacquiao over Bradley.

 

just rewatched Pac-Bradley II maybe I'm still tired but Tim won that fight 6-5-1 I was looking at the skysports version, & much like the first fight watching the replay I had the feeling of "this can't be right", until they stated that going into the 12th rd HBO had Bradley up as well.
To be fair I can see a draw in Mayweather-Maidana I, honestly I was going to make the argument that Pac over Tim in the rematch was better but that Maidana was the physically tougher fighter but now I really can't maybe I'll watch it again later to see if it's just morning eyes but an argument can be made that Bradley should have two wins over Pacquiao.

 

Which is a better win....Pac over Cotto @ catchweight or Floyd over Canelo @ catchweight ?

 

Check this out, I never play that game, I call it the way I see it and that's how I see it. For one Bradey is a small welter and he can't punch, 2 he got too much heart and will be inclined to brawl. He is too small to keep Maidana off his ass and he don't have the skills to evade Maidana's awkward punch selection for twelve rounds. Ruslan was kicking Bradley's ass and Maidana has a better punch selection, Bradley is a sucker for an uppercut and you know Maidana throws those with knockout intentions. Also, have you paid attention to Maidana's jab lately? It's educated, long and with good speed. Plus he works that body and you know what else, he has a dam good trainer. I don't say **** just to be saying it. My opinion is base on the two fighters and what they bring to the table. You can miss me with that bull****.

 

I would say Pacs win as I rate Cotto highly, but I could see an arguement the other way with Canelo never defeated and fresh

 

Let Madaina fight Roidquez and see him KTFO in grand fashion.:deal

 

:huh WTF? I don't even know what you talking about.

 

100% agree.

 

Who would WIN. And how.

Jaun Manuel Roidquez or Marcos Caveman Madaina.


Roidquez KO4:deal