Most overrated individual wins when they happened of the last 5 years?

:good

 

:happy

This should be #1

Quality posts all around though.

 

"Khan was cleaning the floor with him prior to stop" for 2 rounds.

2 rounds.

Khan was dropped multiple times and stopped in less than one third of the scheduled distance.

I would say a better assessment would be that Garcia mopped the floor with Khan, quick.

 

You have to wonder whether Donaire was on top of his game when he got shut out by Rigo.

 

I thought there was a lot of factors at the time he fought Rigo that Donaire didn't do himself any favors (mainly lack of focus) but Donaire hasn't looked good since and in reality, even though he had some decent wins between Montiel and that. Montiel was the last time he looked unstoppable (Navarez and Nishioka didn't seem like they ever tried to beat Donaire).

 

Donaire should take some time off.

 

Cotto's win over Martinez

 

Aye, and they wouldn't be very happy being called British!

 

Given how one-sided Rigo vs Donaire was, I genuinely doubt any version of Nonito would stand a chance. I'm just questioning whether it was as good a win as I initially thought. It does look like Donaire is nowhere near the fighter he was a few years ago.

 

I don't see Khan being a threat to Floyd.

 

most of floyds wins look terrible with age

 

Not at all? The Marquez win was laughed at in 2007 and look at what Marquez went on to achieve.

 

Recent - Tyson fury win over Dereck chisora - simple fact chisora was a fighter on the slide, 20-4 before he faced fury, just a sloppy fighter overall