who do people have as their top 10? with Bradley drawing to chavez (ok iffy decision) who lost to thurman, khan beating dA who best maidana but lost to porter, who lost to brook, positions 3-10 at ww are unclear. Also pac / marquez / Bradley triangle. and factoring in the results at lww with khan beating maidana and Bradley beating DA. mine are fmj pac Bradley khan maidana marquez brook porter alexander Thurman can't help but feel guerrero should be in there somewhere.
Manny Pacquiao Floyd Mayweather Jr Amir Khan Kell Brook Timothy Bradley Juan Manuel Marquez Keith Thurman Marcos Maidana Shawn Porter Devon Alexander
Wow how do people have khan over brook or marquez **** me people love to bandwagon when someone has one.
Maybe not over Marquez but certainly over Brook. Brook has one good win over Porter then a few ok ones against the likes of Senchenko. Really though, I'm not sure we know how good Porter was in the first place.
had khan ahead of brook before DA fight, uk bookies had khan favourite too, marquez I'm unsure about, he's over 40 and its unclear how much he has left.
If Floyd schooled Bradley he wouldn't even be a top 10 ww in your eyes, or you'd make an excuse that he was shot.
Based on resume and what has been proven LATELY, not "who beats who" or "who I like". Nothing they accomplished at 140 matters. I've posted their welterweight records, officially. 1. Floyd Mayweather 10-0 Despite your opinion on him personally, he's only fought champions at 147 lbs lately and has dominated them all so far. 2. Manny Pacquiao 8-2 No doubt the 2nd best, but I don't have him at THE best because of his recent loss and the 2 blown up JR welters he fought. 3. Timothy Bradley 3-1-1 Only lost to Pacquiao and has fought small/blown up welters at 147. Despite them being small welters, he fought the best ones. 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 2-2 He beat Pacquiao at 147, his only notable win at 147. He lost to Bradley. 5. Marcos Maidana 4-3 Has a decent run at welter, only losing once before getting beaten by Floyd twice. 6. Kell Brook 33-0 If I'm not mistaken, he's entire career has been at welterweight. I have him over Khan because he's defeated and earned a belt at 147 by beating an established welterweight in Shawn Porter. 7. Amir Khan 2-0 Looks to be a legit contender at 147, he's not higher on this list because he's only had 2 fights at welter. Neither of those opponents are that good. He beat Alexander, who was beaten by Porter, who was beaten by Brook. Therefore, Brook is higher. 8. Shawn Porter ?-? I don't know his full welterweight history... He only lost to Brook but beat Alexander, so Alexander will be lower. 9. Devon Alexander 10. Keith Thurman Don't have time to elaborate further.
pac is really at 9-1 everyone knew he never lost the first fight against Bradley even the mayweathers