lol Every round was 3 rounds:rofl Then he lost the 4th 10-8 after getting floored. Then after struggling thu the 5th when clearly gassed , he quit. He promised TOS a rematch in the ring. IBF rightfully ranked him above Wlad because of the quit job. Wlad then sued the IBF to get out of the rematch. I can't have you putting blame on Lewis for not excepting rematch when you get behind this terrible behaviour. Tell me why did Wlad rematch Carlos Monroe ? Wlads excuse was he wanted revenge for a head butt that ended the first fight. Why didn't he do the same with Willaimson. You could not even make this shyt up.
It was an of balance knock down, and Wlad won the rest of that round. . Don't act like Williamson was in the lead. You have not clue. He was down 4-1, behind three points on two cards. Jerry Roth 49-46 | judge: Doug Tucker 47-48 | judge: Chuck Giampa 49-46 The fight took place in 2004 A year before Williamson was ko'd in 1 by Mesi. By 2005 Williams lost to Byrd in the worst title match I ever saw. Then in 2007 Meehan stopped him. Simply put there were better out there to fight ( Peter 2005 and Byrd 2006 ) and Williamson was never close to being highly ranked.
No he did not. He was 58-56 ahead after six rounds. That isn't "outboxing". He was narrowly better with half the fight remaining against possibly the worst version of Lewis ever to enter a championship ring with Steward in tow. He didn't "outbox" him. He arguably outfought him for a few rounds before getting stopped. I said it once, I'll say it again, because none of the above contradicts it even slightly: based upon his level of competition the idea that he could "outbox anyone" is preposterous. Too many rounds for what?! Ali beat Liston, ALi outjabbed LISTON, that matters when you are making claims about his outjabbing "anyone". Anyone ever! These statistics don't matter if you meet so few of the top men of the era. Vitali was excellent, but never tested apart from on two occasions when he emerged with losses. How?? Yes, I would love to see proof that fighters like Vitali and Lewis are beyond losing to guys like Muhammad Ali and Larry Holmes, but i'm going to make a wild prediction here and suggest that you won't produce any here. I think that world class, very large fighters are extremely difficult to outbox. Do you really, really think, than you have just "shown" me that? That is common knowledge. Six week fans know this much. If you think it "proves" your incredible claim that Vitali Klitschko could "outbox anyone", I don't really know what to say. It doesn't really matter, does it? Wladimir is obviously the better puncher. Again, you know, it's excuses central for Vitali, but you wanted to hold Machen to losses that he suffered after a total mental breakdown. It's the double standard that infuriates I think Yes, Vitali beat the **** out of him. Hit him over and over and over again with flush power punches. Lewis just stopped him. Real power, I think. Vitali could definitely hit, but you're overselling him in this and every other regard outside of his chin.
Well I had Lewis winning rounds 6,7,8,9,10,11 & 12 during the fight between himself and Vitali, if that's the type of warped logic you wish to promote.
McGrain, You took a scissor to half of my points ( Too much truth on my side..no come backs for you ) and I've seen enough of Ali to know that Vitali would have no F'n problem out boxing the likes of Doug Jones or Jimmy Young, and would have taken Norton out. If you disagree with these points, maybe I should stop replying. You can not produce the reverse proof that Ali and Holmes, two of the best boxers of all time in the division would out box Vitali either, which is why I point to the score cards and performances. How come Vitali never had issues while these two did? Holmes who I think was an even better boxer than Ali could not out box Spinks. But if he had Vitlai's height, power, and activity level...I'm pretty sure he would have. You don't get it when it comes to modern big men who can box.
No, it's not "too much truth for me" it just doesn't mean much. You've posted a long list of "wobbles" and occasions where Vitali hurt guys. None of that changes anything I think or wrote. More than that, this is very hypocritical. You've "scissored" way more of my points than I of yours. Why do you think it's ok to attack me for doing something you've done far more of in this very thread? You will stop replying soon - and it will indeed be based upon something I write that you just find incredible, and impossible, and bizarre. But it will be perfectly normal. I think Ali would outbox Vitali. If you think that that opinion is somehow inarguably wrong, maybe I should stop applying to you. Because Ali fought some of the best fighters in history, and Vitali fought a comparably awful level of competition. I don't have to "Reverse proof" anything. Making out that Vitali would unquestionably defeat Ali because he "outboxed" guys like Larry Donald, Vaughn Bean, Sam Peter and Chris Arreola is drunken. Drunken. Maybe Vitali would have beaten Spinks - if he did, Spinks would be the best scalp of his career by miles and miles - but that doesn't add up to his out-boxing a prime Holmes. I don't think that would happen. I think Holmes would absolutely spank Vitali. We'll never know because a) Vitali will never fight Holmes and b) Vitali only fought a fighter approaching his quality once, and lost. Absurd. What you mean is that I don't rank Vitali highly enough for your liking. I consistently rank Lewis and Wladimir highly.
The problem here is that you are arbitrarily choosing these groups of fighters, to get these results. The criticism leveled at Vitally is based on a measure that we have no control over, i.e. the ranking of his opponents when he fought them.
So using Mendozy's perverted logic. Duran MUST be a better fighter than Hagler because after 13 rounds he was winning on 2 cards, and even on the 3rd. After all 13 rounds is far more exerting than 2.
Does the underlined mean that heavyweights such as pre champion Louis ,Dempsey, Marciano, Langford, Fitz, Charles, Patterson, Schmeling, etc would be cannon fodder for the ranked heavies today? Vitali had no less notice to fight Lewis than Lewis did to fight him, both were in training to fight different opponents and Vitali went to camp first. Vitali has a top chin but definitely is no ATG puncher, his power does not compare to his brothers. Vitali pounded on an old Briggs all night flush punches to the chin, and could not even floor him. He couldnt dent Chisora whom Haye, a good but not great puncher ko'd. He is a good puncher but no ATG
Nope. Sadly that logic is better than Mendoza's logic. Mendoza's logic is that Duran must be better than Hagler...only if Duran got stopped by Hagler in the thirteenth.
No, i'm not doing any of the mad things you did like telling him to **** off and die and trying to fight him at the airport etc.
Give it time. If you were challenged to fight Mendoza during his trip to the Uk you would say no? I am finishing off a bottle of Cotes du Rhone Villages with the other half. Should a post stating Mendoza had died appear , I would open something more substantial. You are constructing concise excellent arguments that are a pleasure to read and presenting points that I would be proud to have made . Problem is you are presenting them to a closed mind. How can that be the action of a sane man?
yes. I'm not fighting anyone from the internet. I remember SuzieQ saying he wanted to fight him too at one point, I think SuzieQ rowed with Mendoza more than you up until about 2008.