His skills are not overrated (minus those anointing him a literal messiah). His resume is however highly overrated. Some people put him on their P4P list over a year ago. Those people would be called idiots.
Funny how you started off by saying this thread is so bad in your 1st post that i didnt know boxing and stuff you said, and then changed your opinion about this thread once you saw people agreeing with me or disagreeing with me and discussing it normally.
Geale's a bum? Top 5 MW, in with a very good shot against Cotto (I'm picking geale by UD). Murray? Top 5 MW and the guy who should have got the nod over Sergio but didn't because Argentina? Macklin? Top 10 at the time. Rubio? Top 10 at the time. You need to stop letting HBO/ESPN/Showtime tell you who's good.
That did nothing to change my opinion. It's a bad thread. At least it's not a troll thread, it's just an uninformed opinion coming from an uninformed poster.
'Man your threads are getting worse and worse. I tried to be nice to you yesterday but it seems like boxing isn't your thing.' Sounds like you're describing this thread to be a troll thread clearly as you marked most of my other threads as troll threads and you said this thread is worse than them basically, then you had to go with the crowd to not look stupid.
The question isn't bad, there are a lot of people claiming he's P4P #1 already and they're getting way ahead of themselves, but your defense of it is. Claiming he has fought only bums displays an unfortunate understanding of the MW division.
If you had more knowledge to back it up this could be a good thread because the question isn't dumb, but sadly the poster is.
There are people on this thread that have agreed he hasn't fought any real good boxers, so basically v bums, have a read...not just my opinion.
Well they also have an unfortunate understanding of the MW landscape then. Tell me which active MWs have fought better competition.