Who has a more legitimate win Cotto over martinez of floyd vs PAc?

Floyd's win more legit...Sergio's entire style was based off movement, etc. From round one the guy couldn't move out there....I like Cotto but he beat up on a cripple for the lineal middleweight championship

 

Pacquiao's condition was not even remotely close to Martinez's. With that said, both guys did to their opponent what no one has ever done. No one has demolished Martinez like that, and no one has ever thoroughly out boxed the great, 8 division champion Manny Pacquiao.

 

Cotto over Martinez isn't legitimate? :nut

 

:roll:

Your legs are vastly more important to boxing than your non-dominant arm.

 

To me personally it's not...dude could not move on fight night

 

I think people are over exaggerating this shoulder tear. Pacquiao didn't look affected by it at all and wasn't in range to throw or land anything anyways. In fact, he threw more after the injury occurred!

 

both fathered them BUT pac is 100x better than serg could ever be.

cotto annihilated serg while Floyd just showed pac the different level of fighter they are on. if Floyd could truly use that numbing (xylodaine sp) )he would be destroying fighters but I think he is too afraid to be a truly one handed fighter in the ring so he just gets respect and that's enough obviously to beat anyone around his size

 

I thought Pacquiao was an ATG only 8-division champion that Floyd was afraid of? Martinez was what? Obviously shot and downhill from his last few fights

Stop hating, give the man his credit.

 

**** you alex

Having a torn rotator tear is some serious stuff and pac went o surgery days after and could be out for 1 year

Pac said every time he threw it it hurt real bad so he didn't want to keep throwing it fool

 

Yet he was more active as the fight progressed and thoroughly outboxed BEFORE the injury :hi:

 

He wouldn't have made it until the 4th (let alone won it with repeated connections on Floyd's head with both hands - and won three of the four subsequent rounds, no less) with a legitimately torn rotator cuff.

 

No its because Pac is a warrior and bad ass he fought through the pain.

Pac went into the bout with a shoulder issue he torn it weeks before it got better but it came back they even asked for a shot before the fight

Pac was preoccoupied with the pain if I was mayweather I would be ashamed to beat a guy coming into a fight with a torn shoulder

the guy is in surgery and MRI scans prove its torn


USADA also knew weeks before team Pac was using creams for the shoulder

 

Don't know how this is a question. Floyd.

Pacquiao beat the #3 P4P fighter in the world in Bradley, while Martinez just s****ed by Euro-level Murray.

 

You've never had a rotator cuff injury. You've certainly never had one and boxed.

 

It's not just about pain, idiot. Legit injuries restrict you, whether it hurts or not. I can't run on a sprained ankle no matter how much of a warrior I am.