The official Mayweather vs. Pacquiao aftermath trash receptacle

:good It is the most inexact of sciences, but it's damn fun.

 

as ive said atg like srr,ali,armstrong,hagler hearns, dont run, im sure you have also a favorite boxer? right? you should open to respect others opinion.

 

Well there were a lot of good fighters pre WW2 :deal

 

I laugh when people write off ATGs without studying them closely because it's easier to remember what you just saw. :thumbsup

 

However true that may be, most of them aren't on the top 10 ATGs list!!! :deal

Floyd will be a top 10 ATG when he retires, it's inevitable. It'll happen.

 

Well that's highly debatable. I happen to think a majority of the top 10 is made up of pre WW2 guys.

 

We'll just agree to disagree. Most of the people on my top 10 ATG list happen to be fighters who fought in the late 40's/50's/60's. :deal

 

No, it wouldn't. Good thing none of my ATGs have that record.

 

No, I haven't seen them lol.

And Pac****s don't really bother me because they don't even pretend to be rational. They're nationalistic and they don't even care.

What bothers me are Fl0mos...they come off as if they think they know things that people who aren't Fl0mos don't know just because their guy is a skill-based fighter. And they tend to measure greatness in terms of earnings, which is weird.

 

:rofl:deal

 

:|:|:|:|:| 118-110. Greatness is making the #2 P4P look like an amateur.

 

right 5 years later:roll:

 

Floyd can't make Balcquiao take a test. Talk to your idol, maybe God wasn't ready to deliver Floyd to his hands :rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl

Floyd owns Pac any time in history. FACT!

 

TOP FIVE (The order can vary but they all remain top 5 and Greb remains #1)
Greb
Langford
Fitzsimmons
SRR
Armstrong
NUMBERS 6-15 (Hard to put in order, but all belong in that range)
Wilde
Charles
Duran
B. Leonard
Pep
Louis
Ali
Tunney
Moore
Walker
NUMBERS 16-30 (Again, I don't really try to put them in order)
Ross
Gans
Monzon
Loughran
T. Gibbons
McFarland
Walcott
Whitaker
JCC
Hagler
Hearns
SRL
Ketchel
Hopkins
Arguello

Here are some names I've seen credibly listed in the top 50 ahead of Mayweather:
Dixon
McGovern
Canzoneri
McLarnin
Saddler
Burley
H. Williams
Conn
M. Spinks
Jofre
I. Williams
Britton
Griffith
Gavilan
Napoles
Bivins

I think there are very strong arguments for placing Mayweather in the top 50. Personally, I have Hopkins, RJJ, ODLH, and Pacquiao ahead of him from this era alone.

I only have strong opinions on the top 5. I can roughly place the top 25-30ish. I wouldn't object to Mayweather being placed in the top 40 or 50, but any better than that would take a lot of justification.

 

floyd made demands because he was afraid of pac:deal

beating up on a past it pac not a great feat. juan did his job for him alreadylol: