Who will rank higher in the ATG list, Joe Calzaghe or Emmanuel Pacquiao?

The question should be, Joe Calzaghe or Floyd Mayrunner?

 

Pacquiao!

 

pac.


joe cal also ranks higher than froid. at leat joe cal slaps people in the face and not in the gloves or neck and without tue.

 

Sven Ottke GOAT!

 

Calzaghe the great arguably the finest Welsh and Italian fighter of all time. Right up there with Rocky Marciano.

 

Pacquiao.no question

 

I dunno about that, rocky defended the full title for years, he didn't defend the tiniest title for all that time.

 

Calzaghe isn't fit to me be named in the same sentence as an 8 time champion . Let the Slapper creep away quietly he isn't a legit ATG anywayatsch

 

:|:|:| Excusequiao beat Margacheato so he is better than zaggers? NO! Manny is the philipino Jeff Lacy.

 

calzaghe is not an atg. he owned the equivalent of the fraduley harrisons wbf title back in the day, nad only in the last leg of his career was he a bona fide champion, unfurtunately for him that was when he was running from every title defence and dropping every title in gibbering fear.

this is not the action of an atg. even sven king of fakery otkke did more.

 

Emmanuel Pacquiao lost to Timothy Bradley, who isn't very good, and Rustico Torrecampo and Medgoen Singsurat who are average contenders.

Joe Calzaghe lost to ... no one. He's 46-0!

He maybe would have lost to the likes of Erik Morales, Juan Manuel Marquez and Floyd Mayweather. We can't know about that. But he wouldn't lose to no namers.

This must be considered when debating ATG'status.

 

46-0.

 

Pacquaio was the only man to LEGITIMATELY beat Margarito since Paul Williams won a close decision. Mayweather had to have Vegas/NSAC conspiracy to beat a basically one armed Pacquaio.

 

ROFLMAO Who did Calzaghe LEGITIMATELY beat He sure as hell didn't beat Bernard Hopkins Slapper couldn't throw a legitimate scoring punch to save his life

 

atsch