Calzaghe aside- who is the GOAT at 168?

I don't tell people not to post replies.

you are trying to censor replies -and I am objecting to your stance, since the forum is for free speech. You are having a hard time admitting your stance, so you replied in this nonsense way,trying to arbitrarily pretend its ME making your mistake.

 

No you havent answered, you have just said some guy, so what is their name they go by?

 

you want me to go find out who the name cowardzaghe on youtube belongs to? how does one do that? it could be anyone in the world. u my as well ask me how many grains of sand there are on Cardiff beach.

they go by the name of cowardzaghe. why are you asking me a question to which you know the answer?


this is your problem failey, you invent a fictional argument when you find the one you were chasing had no basis in reality.

now, who is eric?

 

so i was wrong regarding timing either way this back a fourth dirrvel is boring your copy pasting sh ite

you need to show me where you and super hands own me in every debate :huh other than this joe thread



your a joe fan boy that twist shi t for your agenda

joe could have fought abraham did not

froch did not

bute did not

rematch ried did not

woods did not even though joe had signed to fight him to then pull out to fight saleem

now joe talks sh ite about froch lets his son abuse frochs wife etc etc and when carl ask joe for a straightener

it all goes quite

talks cheap and joe as done his fair share without backing it up when it matters

 

I've been on here for several years and it's always the same 2 or 3 posters that speak incessantly about Joe Calzaghe. He was a good fighter, no doubt about it, but he's not as great as some poeple make him out to be.

The Kessler win was great, no doubt, but how good is Kessler really? Who did he beat up to the point when he fought JOe C? I remember both men being undefeated going into the fight, but what was Kessler's big win that made him such a great fighter up to that point? Who, Andrade?

He beat Lacy, nice win. he also beat Eubank, that was an OK win. I rate the HOpkins win pretty highly, although that version of Bernard was already past it. And I don't rate the ROy Jones Jr fight at all, that was the corpse of Roy, a guy who pretty much was on his downfall by the mid 2000's. I mean after the Glen JOhnson fight, he should've never fought again. All he's been doing is tarnishing his legacy since the mid 2000's.

Calzaghe was very good and deserving of his HOF status. But he is definitely no ATG. He was sequestered in his home country for way too long taking on tomato cans that stat padded his record exponentially. He was past his prime by the time he actually started taking on the top tier guys in and around his weightclass.

 

Carl Froch for me. Why? Cause i like him most

 

hoping froch fights ggg then takes on stevenson at 168 or maybe lhw for his last fight


although i see stevenson maybe sparking carl out at 175 :hey:bolt

 

im hoping he fights GGG too. biiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiig drama show

 

Maybe you can actually see the video, but suddenly got the same illness that affected the eyes of the Judges and Referees that were officiating Ottke fights.

Ottke was outboxing Tate, but if we go by the rules Ottke was supposed to lose by TKO because Sven's cut was caused by a Tate punch.

Good to see you agree Sven Ottke did get "many gift (controversial) decision".