I had Pacman winning 3 rounds. i saw the fight about 5 times now, and I'm certain Pacman won rounds 4,6 and 10. i couldn't give him another round though even if I tried. It's a testament to FLoyd's greatness when his opponents are satisfied just to win a few rounds off of him.
http://i.imgur.com/1aVaA4j.jpg You can watch it again and see Floyd won 1,5,8 and 11 - 4 rounds, that's it. The rest won by Pac.
Maidana- 5/6 rounds Cotto- 4 rounds Guerrero- 2 rounds Pacquiao- 3 rounds Mosley- 2 rounds JMM- 0/1 rounds
I agree. He won about two or three rounds in either fight, but gave Floyd a much tougher fight the first time.
Before I get jumped on, realize that rounds are scored 3 minutes at a time and there are differences between close rounds and blowout rounds and losing 5 close rounds is still losing 5 rounds. I know people struggle to acknowledge scoring criteria, but here we go... Pacquiao- 3 Maidana II- 3 Maidana I- 3 Alvarez- 2 Guerrero- 2 Cotto- 3 Ortiz- 0 Mosley- 1.5 Marquez- 0
Pacquiao: 2 Maidana II: 1/2 (i don't remember this one 100%) Maidana I: 4 Canelo: 0 Guerrero: 2 Cotto: 2 Ortiz:0 Mosley: 1 Marquez: 0
Cotto fought him the best, even if he only actually won 4 rounds. Maidana won 4 rounds if you're generous. Both did much better than Pac.