Besides Mayweather/ Pacquiao / Marquez, head to head, who the best Welterweight?

Besides Mayweather, Manny Pacquiao and the inactive Marquez, head to head (not based on resume) who the best welterweight around? :think

 

The answer is The Special One™ Kell Brook

 

Tim Bradley and i don't even like the guy

 

Its not even close really bradley is a amazing fighter his resume is the stuff of legends the guy is one of the toughest fighters out there

I dont even like him.........

 

He went life and death with Chaves, Provodnikov, Marquez and lost to Pacquiao twice.

The Special One™ would beat those four ham and eggers in the same night. :nod

 

Bradley, easily. Who has Brook beaten other than Porter? Seriously, this is no contest. Bradley is the best welterweight under your criteria.

 

Lmfao. I come into this thread and everyone of you trolling phaggots is on my ignore list. Eat a d*ick *****es.

 

Notice the term in the title 'head to head' and not resume. Fights aren't fought with resumes.

 

Not based on resume I think it's Thurman. Mostly because Bradley has been on the decline.

And Brook...eh, I don't really see it.

 

1/2 = Thurman/Brook

3/4 = Porter/Maidana

 

Yes but just because we feel one guy beats 7 of the others listed doesn't mean we can't favor the worst guy on the list to defeat him... Styles, my friend.

 

Doesn't matter. Brook beats the lot. And if you struggle pick who'd beat most fighters.

 

Alexander should be ahead of Maidana.

And Khan :nod

 

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao

3. Bradley

4/5/6/7. Maidana (rank this group in whatever order you like. little between them)
4/5/6/7. Brook
4/5/6/7. Khan
4/5/6/7. Thurman

8. Porter (pretty much hanging onto the group above)

9. Chaves
10. Alexander

Marquez pretty much retired...only good for a Pacquiao skrap these days.

 

Brook clearly, Bradley closest behind him, then Spence & Thurman.