Why are people still saying that JMM's punch in r6 would have knocked out anyone?

Never!

 

My avatar for years on this site was a picture of Mayweather's head on a chickens body.

As far as I'm concerned PBF's chin is proven, he took shots from Judah, Mosley and Maidana and was caught flush and didn't legitimately hit the deck. Mosley's a much bigger puncher than JMM at any weight.

It's definitely more speculative to say that JMM's punch would have KO'd anybody than not because all we know is that it KO'd that fighter, where as when fighter who haven't been KO'd have taken big shots they have stayed upright eg. PBF.

JMM's KO of Pac was one of the most brutal in recent times, someone with a strong chin doesn't get KO'd like that in that fashion, he was asleep for 5 minutes for christ sake.

 

Money is the most skilled defensive fighter I have ever seen. Never careless, cautious and calculated.....but, Let him get hit with a good shot he does not see. He will go down.

Its not the ones you see its always the ones you dont see.

 

That is what you speculate.

I, on the other hand, choose to speculate that had Floyd jumped face first into a JMM brutal counter (that he had been practicing to administer in just that situation for months ahead of time, btw), he'd have slept as long or longer than the Pacman.

See how that works?

 

Much bigger punchers than JMM land flush shots regularly in boxing in all divisions and don't achieve such devastating results. So again all we can say is that punch KO'd that fighter and NOT that punch would have KO'd anybody.

 

The same shot, in the same situation would have ko floyd. No need to discuss this.

 

Name one fight I will go to you tube and watch. Money sees every punch so let me see this fight were he was careless and got caught.

 

Manny walked(ran) right onto a punch. he added power to that shot in doing so.Not everyone walks onto shots like that, but when and if they do, KO is the usual result :deal

 

Check out vs Mosley round 2 i thinK?

 

He saw that punch thats not getting caught when you see it.

Like I said its the punch you dont see.

 

I'm speculating based on having watched a bunch of fighters (great and otherwise) get hit by and react to a bunch of punches. The KTFO6 sequence is definitely one of the most violent and conclusive I've ever seen.

Floyd never leapt into a giant, premeditated, calculated counter, did he?

He never got hit with anything like that punch (due to his great defense). So to say that he without doubt would survive that experience is horrible speculation.