In order to be in the P4P running, you need to be currently viable. I love Manny but he shouldn't even be in the P4P. He is WAY past his prime. The only 2 that deserve to be on that list of the 5 listed above are GGG and Roman. Ward probably will be when he fights again but he has been inactive too long to be in it. Rigo is gifted but P4P, I don't think so. That's another thing that should be a requirement. The audience has to be entertained when you fight. Rigo is disqualified for that reason.
Totally agree about the rigo point. Maybe mayweather should have been disqualified since his welter days.
I can't give you an unbiased opinion on Mayweather because he is as bad as Rigo. No entertainment value for me. The last entertaining Mayweather bout was when he fought Castillo, in my book.
Wladimir. Absolutely no question about it. This guy runs an entire division for 9 years straight undefeated. He beat every up-and-comer, and dominantly so. Only Mayweather was superior achievement-wise, and now he's retired. I'm the first one to criticize his questionable "tactics" in the ring, but clinching only gets you so far. This guy has proven for nearly a decade that he's head and shoulders above everyone else. Who gives a **** if he only fights in one division?
It's clearly Gonzalez. His last two wins alone trump a lot of fighters whole resumes. Only Manny Pac and Ward can compete with Roman atm
RG is extremely talented, technically sound. However, the one thing I have noticed about him is that he leaves himself open at times. That probably is due to his sense of invincibility. He is so much better than his opponents. But if he ever does run into a real puncher, he better be careful.
Pacquiao if active and winning as he has a lot more good wins on record than anyone else, Gonzalez and Klitschko very close behind though in my opinion. As we are probably assuming Pacquiao has one fight left I don't really think he can be included, so probably just shade to Klitschko.