Comparing Thurman, Brook and The Ring RATINGS!

i want to have a good non bias discussion for this thread!

How in hell Brook its ahead of Thurman in The Ring rankings?

Thurman had a way better resume and he had beat way better opposition in better fashion! Also he is more charismatic than Brook which helps to sell more for the boxing average fan aka ala GGG

Your thoughts?

 

Thurman has a way better resume? How so?

 

Cause Brook is better than him, easy

 

Quintana- ex champion at 147
Diego ChaveS- top 10 welter who just came from a draw to bradley
Robert Guerrero- 4 division champ
Luis Collazo- ex champion at 147

Whats Brook best win? Shawn Porter??? In a ugly close fight? Man step up your boxing iq:good

 

Basesd on what? Fighting unknown bums in the Uk? atsch

 

Thurman almost got KO'd by an ancient and shot Collazo that Khan dominated for 12 rounds

#khansleftovers

 

I don't think thurman is carasmatic at all. He comes across as loud and stupid but quiet dense.

 

Hahahahahahahahahahah :rofl Almost got kod? Man stop smoking crack :-(

 

Thurman folded over and was grimacing in pain like a woman during childbirth

 

Man serious why cant you talk real boxing?atsch

 

I did homie. Thurman was folded over and on the verge of being stopped. :hi:

 

Pass me the pipe baby boy:rofl

So brook win againts porter in really ugly close fight was amazing? atsch

 

Brook beating Porter is better than any single win on Thurmn's resume. Thurman has been hurt in a bunch of fights against lesser opposition. Chavez, Collazo, Soto Karass, etc, and he hasn't looked as dormant recently. Almost like he's lost something.

 

Brook beating Porter is better than any of Thurman's wins. I'd say that is pretty much the long and short of it.

 

That's an exaggeration. He was hurt yes. But Collazzo would have to have put together quite a bit more together to stop him. That's would be akin to saying that Brook was jelly legged by Senchenko.... And was on the verge of being stopped.