How Can Hagler Be An ATG Middle?

I get what you're doing and why, but stop, please. :exmad

 

Little-known fact: When Roberto Duran was born, he weighted in at somewhere south of 108 pounds, so it's actually even worse than you describe. Duran is actually a blown-up light-flyweight.

Hagler is clearly not what he seems.

 

Have you had a bang on the head? How about beating all Comer's for 7years.

 

Littler-known fact: half of that consisted of the partly digested remains of Duran's twin brother, Eddie Duran, consumed in the womb by Roberto somewhere in the final trimester. Putting his true birth weight somewhere around the measly 59lb mark, so he's a blown up half-fly.

The vicious bastard. :verysad

 

I do not disagree with any of this, however, Hagler's competition was better than Monzon's. :deal

I also said that Hagler declined moving up to light heavy.

As for the Antuofermo draw, that was a case of bad judging. Monzon, by the way, is a king of the draws. He had nine of them If there is a video of all of them, I'd wager most would score a loss or two for CM.

 

How can Sugar Ray Robinson be an ATG welterweight?

He beat:

Henry Armstrong, blown-up featherweight
Kid Gavilan, blown-up bantamweight
Fritzie Zivic, blown-up featherweight
Sammy Angott, blown-up featherweight
Marty Servo, blown-up lightweight
Bernard Docusen, blown-up featherweight

 

And how many top ranked black fighters did he face? Enjoying this game.

 

:yep

 

And Jake LaMotta, weight-drained light-heavy. :good

 

Let's take a quick survey of respected boxing historians' stances on Robinson and whether the consensus view is holding whatever top ranked black fighters he didn't fight against him to such a point that it detracts from his generally accepted position at or near the apex of the p4p heap?