I think it's hands down Toney. I've been watching him a lot on youtube recently. It was a sight to behold. Watch him now. Amazing.
Look at his body attack. His ring IQ and varied offensive ****nal. He was also very crafty defensively.
Toney struggled with lateral movement he also couldn't set traps like Hopkins. Hopkins hands down had the higher ring IQ.
H2H Toney defeats Hopkins. He doesn't have to worry much about speed because Hopkins isn't a mover. Toney would land on the body all night. His workrate was also really high. He's too much for Hopkins.
Hell no Hopkins would outbox toney on the outside he's just too good for toney who loved guys who came at him but with Hopkins he'd be fighting someone who wouldn't play his game.
A body attack isn't going to be a factor because this fight is going to be fought at Hopkins range Hopkins would dictate the distance in this fight and be the ring general.