How does a prime 140 Hatton do in today's division?

Love to see anyone mop the floor with Broner. He is a very unlikable guy, and is quite delusional as well. I found the Maidana fight very funny.

 

Once again, you never actually refuted his point.

 

His point was that Fluid ducked Hatton at 140. Then he said that Fluid fought a drained DeLaHoya at 154 to bolster his argument. I disagree with both.

 

Great post

 

It wouldn't be quite as satisfying as the beating Maidana gave him, I don't think, but it'd be up there.

 

That doesn't refute anything. Sorry to pick on you out of all the people on this forum that do this but why jump into an argument if you're just going to end it by saying you disagree. He pointed out several things that support his argument and all you said was " I disagree".

 

I never got the sense that you were "picking on me". I did refute what he wrote. I wrote that Mayweather naturally or unnaturally grew into 147, as most boxers move up and not down, where he spent the majority of the rest of his career. He wrote that after they both became 140 pound champs, Mayweather fought once more at 140 against Sharnba Mitchell, then moved up to welterweight to avoid Hatton. Do you believe that Fluid moved up to 147 to avoid Hatton?

 

The fight against Sharnba Mitchell was his WW debut. Should I use that to discredit your argument like you did before?

 

Not at all. I was mistaken. I erred. Not the 1st time, won't be the last. Thanks for pointing that out to me:good. Come to think of it, if anything, you just reinforced my point, because if you're right, and I have no reason to disbelieve you, then Fluid moved up immediately after winning that version of the 140 pound title rather then fight someone else at 140, thereby, according EnzoRD, avoiding Hatton. Don't know if you've noticed, but he never responded to my post which outed his lie, or the 2 questions I asked him. Know what? Maybe he didn't lie. Maybe he was just too embarrassed to admit he was wrong (like I did when I was).

 

Doesn't matter to me. Forums were just slow and I felt like arguing with somebody. Though my fight with was on the way people like to argue. I've done my fair share of May/Pac arguing in the past and I don't care to continue. Who was right or wrong was irrelevant to me. Thats what I meant by picking on you though. I just chose somebody to gripe at. I wasn't on either side of the argument.

 

I love how this turned into a mayweather thread lol