Are there any ATG heavyweights that actually fought each other at both their peaks?

Again, Ali wasn't prime in the first one.

 

Patterson and Spinks weren't prime.

 

I agree, later Ali was stronger.


Frazier vs Foster
Ali vs Foster . . . Ok technically Foster was not an all time great AT heavyweight.

 

Lol someone said that liston was not in his prime against patterson . yeah he was born in 1500 shut the ****

 

And some ****ing idiots saying that ali 71 was in his prime. Stupid trolls

 

-Louis vs Schmeling
-Clay vs Frazier
-Tyson vs Spinx
-Bowe vs Holy
-Lewis vs Klitxhko (OK Lewis's last fight, but he was still fighting at a high level by the end of his career)

 

Holyfield-Bowe and Norton-Holmes/Foreman may fit the description, depending on your ranking of Bowe/Norton. Outside of that, no.

 

Holy-Bowe is a good call. Bowe was a near-great, I would say.

Ali-Frazier obviously has to be up for some consideration. Ali was not peak, but he was pretty damn good still, and in some respects he was a better fighter in the 70's.
Joe was as good in that fight as he could ever be.

The problem with Tyson-Spinks is that Spinks in no way was a Great heavyweight. Not even close, I'm afraid.

 

Povetkin-wlad

Haye-wlad if you want to go there

 

No and no.

 

They're both going in the hof and I'd favor both over Norton.