Why does everyone rate the fab 4 greater than Floyd

You're going to compare those guys to Hearns, Ray and Duran?

 

Didn't you know, its a fact retired fighters who lost to fighter's that couldn't hold his jock are way greater.

Doesnt matter what one thinks, the fab 4 was because they had 4 evenly matched fighters. Fab 4 is rivaled by
Morales,jmm, mab and pac. 4 evenly matched fighters who couldn't hold fmj jock, yet some think they're close ..

Get a grip

 

the so called fighter of the decade and fighter of our era who was smaller was even fought when he was past prime on uneven playing field and very defensive mode, how much more he fab 4.lol

 

Floyd has got skills, in his early days he looked like the best thing I've ever seen skill-wise, but he is not cut from the same cloth as those guys. You can debate it for the rest of history but you'll never convince a ton of people from thinking that way

 

Although I will admit sugar Ray could be a pain in the ass

 

Cognitive dissonance much?

 

Actually Sugar Ray may have pulled some diva at times....but he still got in there with a young Terry Norris.... and there is no way in hell that Floyd Mayweather would ever ever ever do something like that

 

Floyd's the best of this generation no doubt but H2H against the fab 4,it's possible he can beat them all, but it would be hell of tough to do it.. Floyd would get busted up in every single individual fight against the Fab 4. That's for sure.

 

Looking at what Castillo, de la Hoya, maidana, and Mosley were able to do to Floyd imagine what the fab 4 would do. Floyd also would lose to Aaron Pryor at 140, terry Norris at 154, Simon brown at 147-154. He'd get smacked by McCallum at 154, he'd also get smacked by starling.

 

I'd bet arguello over Floyd as well

 

And maybe lloyd honeyghan

 

Put him H2H against 130-135lb ATGs and you have a conversation...young Floyd against that Duran

 

Apocalypse time.

 

Leonard & Hearns were naturally bigger, as was Hagler. I think Mayweather should be rated higher than Hearns P4P but would have a very hard time head to head because of Hearns size.

Leonard is a better P4P great and Id favor him H2H

Duran is considered the greatest LW but honestly Floyd is a tough match up for him stylistically. That might be a 50-50 fight.

Hagler is so much bigger. I think you can rate Floyd higher P4P. They would never fight H2H.