Who do you rate higher as an ATG and why? W Klitschko or E Holyfield

We are not talking about Bowe being in shape or not. This is what I mean when I say you dont pay attention.
Also this silly comment of did I watch boxing then, when you know I was and you were possibly not even born.
I pity the youth of today with you claiming to be teaching them

 

I have found many times, he gets confused and doesnt read what is written. I have seen him call fights and then go back on it, then forward and then back again.

 

I did.
Lufc is really not the brightest

 

He was pointing to the fact that you were only picking parts of the post that you wanted to read and missing out parts that didnt suit your reply.
Tell me what you think were Bowes 3 biggest wins. I will give you a chance to try and find old footage of before you were born

 

So you disagree that I said Holyfield 3 was arguably Bowes biggest win
See below

"Amazingly Lufc doesnt view that as arguably Bowes biggest win in stopping Holyfield. It would be between that win and his first win IMO. I would probably guess that Lufc hasnt read the post properly"

Your answer above is to say probably (which indicates it could be one or the other) Holyfield 1 or 3, so you think the stopping of Holyfield is arguably Bowes biggest win.
I cant believe that you are a teacher. Thats a real worry for the youth of today.

Well im sure being born in 87 that you were watching Bowe and Holyfield 1 as it unfolded

 

You wrote probably Holyfield 1, Holyfield 3 which could mean its debateable as to which. Which I feel it is. Stopping Holyfield is arguably Bowes biggest win. Even if you dont think it is, and I do think its debateable, Explain how you dont think it is arguable. This will be good.
I know you dont teach boxing history

 

As we know, you were ot watching boxing back then and Holyfield wasnt coming back with heart troubles. He had been out of the ring for over a year after that fight with Moorer and came back and fought a sensational battle looking impressive against Mercer. In fact it was noted just how impressive Holyfield was, so stop trying to make out he was a faded fighter. He went on to twice beat Tyson and push L Lewis in a return

 

I wrote the win is arguable. Not better or worse but arguable. Pay attention.
As for faded. That is a ridiculous comment and shows that you did not watch Holyfields comeback fight with Ray Mercer. As I noted you are too young to know. So you must also feel that after that he was faded when avenging the Moorer win, beating Tyson and pushing L Lewis.
Answer this. If you feel Bowe was also out of shape, how do you think he was able to comeback from a bad knockdown and stop Holyfield when L Lewis couldnt on two ocassions put much of a dent in Holyfield

 

You say "don't think it is arguable" yet wote probably before. Think!
So lets get this completely understood.

- You werent watching boxing then and was a small child when these bouts were taking place. But feel Holyfield was faded and past prime in the space of 2 years and 2 because he was stopped by Bowe and was unwell when he fought Moorer a year and a half previously

- You didnt watch Holyfields bout against Mercer after the Moorer fight where he was credited with such a good performance

- You are implying that Holyfield being unwell against Moorer ended his best days and made him faded to what he was from there on in when




He was then diagnosed as having a noncompliant left ventricle. Holyfield retired as a result. [4] A couple of months later, Holyfield said he had been cured by evangelist Benny Hinn. [5] Holyfield went to the Mayo Clinic and was given a clean bill of health. He was told the heart condition appeared because he was over-medicated and over-hydrated in the treatment he received after the Moorer fight. [6] Years later, Dr. Margaret Goodman, former chairman of the medical advisory board of the Nevada State Athletic Commission, said the medical arm of the commission questioned Holyfield about possible HGH use. "There were questions [because] the abnormalities Evander had with his heart were findings that could have been consistent with growth hormone use," she said. "The problem was there was no test and Evander denied any use of growth hormone." [7]

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php?title=Fight:8271



Point is nothing you have said is beyond doubt. Quite the opposite if you had of watched the Mercer fight after the Moorer fight