Who do you rate higher as an ATG and why? W Klitschko or E Holyfield

Do you enjoy watching Holyfield fights?

 

The 00s and teens are/were bummy eras

 

Holyfield all the way....His opposition was worldclass where Wlad fought in the weakest era ever...H2H Holyfield takes Wlad out inside 6 rounds...

 

Without Vitali there's no Wlad reign. Very unlikely Wlad beats Corrie Sanders in a rematch and then where would he have been? Wlad's next fight after Corrie Sanders he barely survived a journeyman he was so ruined.

 

Holyfield, I rate as high as Apple pie.
Klitschko, I rate as high as a rhubarb pie.

 

Then watch his fights again and see if your opinion changes.

 

Holyfield has the better resume and boxing skills.

 

Do you know the definition of insanity?

 

If you touch Wladimir he becomes a nervous wreck. Thats why he has to have a ref on his side to help him win.
I wouldn't put him in the top 50 tbh

 

Yes I do. It's arguing endlessly over something which is ultimately subjective and thinking there could be any kind of resolution. Your opinions are so diametrically opposed and - as is tradition in online debate - neither is prepared to budge an inch. That said, it's an interesting read and food for thought. Kudos.

 

I've asked him to watch some fights and make his own mind up. Bailey loves to argue with boxrec and stats and figures. He doesn't so much like to watch the actual fights.

Throughout I've maintained that for me his performances from MM onwards are not as good as they were before MM. If he disagrees that is his opinion.

 

holyfield= fought better fighters