Castillo, Maidana, the DQ against Judah and Pacquaio, you could add ODLH in but was a close call. So in noway is he undefeated.
He should be 46-2-1 L Castillo 1 L DQ Judah D Maidana 1 But his official record is 49-0 and he's an ATG.
I concur with your thoughts, largely. Not sure about the ATG, though. For me, you have to be the top 5 or 10 of all time to be an ATG. It gets bandied around a little too much for my liking.
Fair enough, I consider Felix Trinidad and Joe Calzaghe to be an ATG and they're not even ATG Top 100's. My terminology goes: GOAT level ATG-> Higher end ATG -> higher-mid etc. and same structure for HOF level fighters who aren't ATG's. I consider Barrera and Morales as ATG's aka 'Greats', for example.
He lost the first Castillo fight, the first Maidana fight, and the first Pacquiao fight. He always rematches the guys who beat him.
He is but he is also winless, as once it was revealed beyond question he was a cheat (the IV gate that even his nut huggers can't defend) all his wins should've been changed to NC's
Well that depends, he actually is undefeated, but I think you're trying to troll, I'll take the bait. Yes he's undefeated
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationalization_(psychology) psychology and logic, rationalization or rationalisation is a defense mechanism in which controversial behaviors or feelings are justified and explained in a seemingly rational or logical manner to avoid the true explanation, and are made consciously tolerable—or even admirable and superior—by plausible means.
Of course he is. The question is ridiculous, and smacks of an agenda. Anti-Mayweather fans may not like it, but according to his official ledger, he is unbeaten. End of story.
His greatest victory was doing illegal IV and getting away with it. How can you can get caught doing illegal IV at home and still get away.
With all due respect I disagree.. In my personal opinion Floyd Mayweathers record reads 44-4-1 n/c Losses .. Castillo 1 Maidana 1 Ortiz 1 DQ loss Cortez never said box on Judah Automatic DQ When Roger entered the ring & attacked Judah The no contest was Pacquaio on May2 2015. This result should have been amended after the 750 ml ILLEGAL saline debacle. Also a full investigation into the affair should have been held as no logical explanation was ever offered by Mayweather or the NSAC as to why Floyd needed 750 ml of saline administered illegally. Any doctor or nurse will tell you that any person needing 750 ml of saline drip for dehydration would be in ICU 24 hours later not in a boxing ring Lastly I am NOT anti Mayweather as such but I am anti corruption in the sport I love Just my honest opinion for what its worth