De la Hoya, Trinidad, Mosley - in what order do you rank them?

This.

 

I'll have to watch the fights between these 3 again to decide who goes where.
Those were close fights. These 3 ought to be considered close.

 

You rank Oscar highest by a mile despite being 0-3 against these guys??

 

How did everyone score the fights ?
They all looked pretty close to me.

 

I personally scored De La Hoya-Trinadad 7-5 Oscar so no robbery IMO. Oscar should have won that fight easily but Oscar only has himself to blame for making it a close fight.

Oscar-Mosley I was a clear as day Mosley win IMO. Oscar-Mosley II should be a no contest really, but as for who "won" the fight, i know many call it a robbery, i though Oscar probably deserved to win but it was a very close fight IMO.

The fact is though he's 0-3 against them.

 

Even if you ignore the fact that if the judges were looking at the fights correctly and had him 2-1 in those fights, are you really going to ignore the career arcs of all three and not see the larger body of work DLH did? Head to head is only one aspect of ranking them and not really the most accurate anyway, because using that method assumes the respective opponents are all at their absolute best and doesn't factor styles into anything. That matters too.

It just so happens that they WERE at or near their respective best during this time, but still......

 

De la Hoya.
Trinidad.
Mosely.

 

De La Hoya
Mosley
Trinidad

Numbers 65,66,67 respectively on my atg list.

Numbers 10,11,12 respectively on my WW list.