How would prime Calzaghe have done in THE SUPER SIX??

The reason I'm using them to back up my point, is because they had similarities to Andre, but overall, they were lesser fighters. Which means it's both illogical and ignorant to assume that Joe would have clowned Andre with absolute ease.

Yes, Andre vs Joe would have been a pick em fight, pitting 2 elite fighters against each other who both possessed great attributes. It would have been very intriguing.

Now you can see why I'm arguing with the TS who's an absolute cretin.

 

You haven't offered an actual breakdown at all. No an*lysis, no logical examples backing up your opinion etc. Just an emotion filled rant of what you'd have hoped to have seen happen, completely disregarding the fact that Joe couldn't humiliate lesser fighters with similar attributes.

I'm also still waiting for the list of southpaws that Joe fought, which would give credence to your opinion of how he'd have embarrassed Dirrell and Dawson.

 

Does Calzaghe come out of retirement to fight in the super 6? In that case I dont think he does that well. But insert prime or near prime calzaghe in and he would win

 

Whats laughable. Calzaghe made top SMWs look like amateurs and the S6 had his leftovers and leftovers of leftovers competing to get a name at SMW after the void he left

 

The problem with Loudon is that he posts from his opinion rather than facts that are available and even when you show him facts he argues them with his opinion when facts are present. He will quote things saying what fighters were thinking even though nobody knows what someone is thinking.
I expect he has done it on this thread alone. In fact I am so sure, I will scan a couple of them and quote where he has done it

 

Calzaghe was a clear winner against Reid in a pro Reid crowd with a badly damaged hand and problems leading up to the fight, he clearly beat Bika and had Hopkins hanging on to survive.

 

Is Calzaghe in the super six instead of ward?

 

There we go, Loudon talking the mental state of someone. Yet Joe did overwhelm his opponents. That was often how he won

 

Why do all these posters go on about Dirrell. Look at how Dirrell lost to Froch and Degale and tell me how he would have beaten Calzaghe. He wouldnt.
We are talking a S6 competition that had some good SMWs but they didnt have a great SMW which is what Calzaghe was. Im not even convinced Ward would have faced Calzaghe. Ward didnt face boxer movers or speedy fighters. He didnt face Dirrell, wasnt interested in Bute and didnt face Degale. All fast boxer movers and not as fast, skilled, with the great workrate, chin and skill of Calzaghe.
I agree, that I feel Calzaghe would easily win the S6