Joe Jeannette V Jack Dempsey,Joe Louis,Jack Johnson?

You have seen the same amount of footage pn Jeannette as Klompton has, minus perhaps some non boxing footage with Jeannette in it.

 

The krapper is a fraud but what gets me is his childish attitude, "na na I have it and you dont, na na". I could watch YT and see all I want and I dont have to kiss krappers bu tt tocks. I mean he's a grown a ss man and acting like a child it's amazing. "ha ha I have it you dont!", gimme a break!

 

Aaaah, once again pretending to know whats in my collection. Please, illuminate us. What exactly do I have in my collection on Jeanette?

 

And again, this fraud is the only reason you got to see your hero in action. So everytime you call me a fraud we both know you are puckering up and kissing my ass. When you contribute anything to the history of the sport beyond loaning a scrapbook to a guy who wrote a piece of **** fictionalized account Jeanettes life then get back to me. Until then you didnt even write a piece of **** fictionalized account of Jeanettes life, you just contributed a few biased articles to it.

 

First off there are no rules that limit your answers to a yes or no, if my answer is vauge that's cos I dont play fantasy boxing. My opinion, your opinion, anybody opinion, is just that an opinion. It's like saying who would win tween King Kong and Godzilla, it dont mean a thing. I did give you my opinion apparently it upsets you.

My position on this "crusade", is that Jennette was not overrated, he deserved respect he wasnt an also ran, he earned his place in the big four. You and your friend always looking for negatives. I posted what his contemporaries said about him, you on the other post who he lost to and how he lost to clutch n grab, but fail to say he was an inexperienced fighter, which is relevant. You and your partner on the other hand look to pyss on everybody's parade.

A perfect example is your post dealing with some offer for a fight between clutch n grab and Jennette in NY that the boxing commission vetoed. Was that a surprise to you??? All the big four done very well overseas, if the fight could have been done Europe would have been the place.

You are free to post all the articles and quotes you want. But when you do expect a response as I expect a response.

Fact is Jennette was highly thought of by his contemporaries and earned his spot on the big four. Along come pysstorians 90 yrs later and pyssing on Jennette's grave and claim he is overrated by historians who have never seen him in person. When even C&G himself is clearly saying that Jennette belonged.
Please explain if Jennette was such a bum, how he slipped into the big four? "O but he lost to Thompson, lol. File that under "SO WHAT".

Old clutch n grab, himself said the following:

Jennette is a tough fighting proposition. I’m not afraid to face him in a ring, but I would much rather fight Sam Langford or Sam McVey-JJ

Jennette is the toughest man I ever fought and the hardest to hurt. Why the more I hit that man the stronger he got. No wonder he beat Sam McVey in a finish fight-JJ

****Remember this was an inexperienced Jennette C&G is talking about

Joe Jennette was the toughest man I ever saw and Sam Langford was the most dangerous-JJ

How is this possible that Johnson himself said these things when you 90yrs later point out Jennette lost to Thompson in his PD, as if that justifies your position.

Give the man his due, he earned it the hard way, by actually fighting some of the toughest guys at that time.

 

mcvey,
You don't think its childish resorting to calling a poster who has been polite to you names just because you have no answer to the facts he has presented?

Um, wat fact's, that C&G beat an inexperienced Jennette, but fails to mention that C&G had way more experience than a 4 fight Jennete or even a 22 fight pro. That fact??
Are you saying the prof was polite, it must be love cos you overlook his sarcasm and his snide remarks. Polite, give me a break, jeez.
Maybe you missed it but I tend to respond to every single remark posed.

You're like a kid who has been outclassed in a friendly kick -around and now, after an attack of the sulks says," I'm taking my ball and I'm going home.
Excellent using what I posted many threads ago talking about the same person.
This is your partners exact response, "you'll never see another Jennette fight to some other poster, lol. "I'm taking my ball and I'm going home."haha

 

Do you have any modern [postWW2 ,] lists that feature Jeannette in a Heavyweight All Time Top Ten ? I ask because Johnson ,Louis,and Dempsey are routinely included in them, but I've never seen Jeannette's name in one! The very latest one, in this month's Ring,has the following:
1.Ali
2.Louis.
3.Johnson
6.Dempsey[/QUOTE]

Again, cos apparently you missed the point, I never mentioned rankings, I dont get into fantasy boxing, and I dont think he was overrated and I dont think he was as bad as you paint him out to be.

This post by you is silly the Ring ratings what does that prove, nada zlich. I never said he was a top 10 guy, and this ranking is what? 100yrs later, FYI 'The Ring', is not as highly thought of today as it was in Nat's day. So why bring it up? O I know you think it justifies your position that Jennete was nothing. Why disregard what his contemporaries and even Johnson chimed in. But of course you know better 100yrs later lol

 

Ah, but who cares? Keep your collection I'd much rather go to YT, watch as many fights as I want without having to kiss your a ss

 

Childish attitude?....try looking in the ****ing mirror.

 

Really who are you addressing? Address me, I am the one posting. OMG you didnt mention "biased" you who live by biased and agenda filled articles bahahaha.
You who doesnt know the difference 'tween a contract, an offer and an agreement, please. Why are you so jealous that somebody is writing a book on Jennette's life. I know a fine pysstorian as yourself should know it's a writer prerogative to write what they want, who are you to say anything when all you done is mostly "write" a cut a paste book.

 

I have, since I dont tell anybody if you dont agree with me, you wont see anymore clips of whoever. Or I have it you dont. That's childish, if you dont think that's childish no problem, I however do.