McGirt vs. Chavez @ 147

Chavez is the better fighter here. But, at 147, McGirt probably wins a decision. 147 was a bridge too far for Chavez.

 

I think a prime version of McGirt @ 147 would decision Chavez.

 

Yeah, JCC is no welter and Buddy presents all the wrong problems for him fighting up a division beyond his ability to perform at a world-class level.

 

Too bad McGirt hurt his arm. A potential really great welter champ who few remember today.

 

James McGirt UD12 JC Chavez

 

You remember his shoulder going in the Leon fight?..He had to seriously use every trick in the book to survive. Warrior in that fight, should've probably been pulled it was that bad

 

He has a chance.Chavez was a great fighter,McGirt very ,very good ,as good as you can be without being great,similar to Billy Graham.

 

The more I think about it...Chavez would have a solid shot. Meldrick Taylor overwhelmed McGirt with speed...and while Chavez didn't have that type of speed, he was very accurate, and better defensively than Taylor, also had a better plan of attack for winning a fight. Chavez does have a chance...a solid one.

 

At beginning of 93 McGirt was top ranked WW. He then survived
2 Championship fights with Whitaker with one arm and without his
fav punch the left hook. James had won the title from a rugged
fighter in Simon Brown. Julio best weight was LW and was at his
most vulnerable at WW. James on pts.

 

At 147 I like McGirt in this one

 

McGirt wasn't that big so I don't think size would be a factor. He was so slick though. He avoided punches but always looked to land shots. Great counter puncher. Could chavez break him down? Close one but I think McGirt by decision. Maybe.

 

McGirt at his best here? I think he gets a unanimous points win ,Catching Chavez more than at any other point in his career .

 

McGirt by close decision if the judges are not bought off.

 

Concur ^.