the what fights did you watch today\scorecard thread.

Oba Carr - Livingstone Bramble

Rd 1 - 10-7, Bramble
Rd 2 - 10-9, Carr
Rd 3 - 10-9, Carr
Rd 4 - 10-9, Bramble
Rd 5 - 10-9, Carr
Rd 6 - 10-9, Bramble
Rd 7 - 10-9, Bramble
Rd 8 - 10-9, Bramble
Rd 9 - 10-9, Bramble
Rd 10 - 10-9, Bramble

97-91, Bramble

 

Dude, I did this one about a year ago. We're almost identical on scores. How is it the judges couldn't see it if you and I are almost exact?

Livingstone Bramble vs. Oba Carr

Round 1: 10-7 Bramble (Carr down twice this round)
Round 2: 10-9 Carr
Round 3: 10-9 Carr
Round 4: 10-10 Even
Round 5: 10-9 Carr
Round 6: 10-9 Bramble
Round 7: 10-10 Even
Round 8: 10-9 Bramble
Round 9: 10-9 Bramble
Round 10: 10-9 Bramble

Total: 97-93 Bramble

Officially this was a split decision for Carr. But I cannot make a case for Carr in this one. After 5 five rounds he would only fight in spurts - winning the early part of a round and then succumbing to Bramble's body blows and simply hanging on. I love Carr's stylish boxing, but Bramble was robbed.

 

Larry Holmes - Michael Spinks I

Rd 1 - 10-9, Holmes
Rd 2 - 10-9, Holmes
Rd 3 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 4 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 5 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 6 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 7 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 8 - 10-9, Holmes
Rd 9 - 10-9, Holmes
Rd 10 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 11 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 12 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 13 - 10-9, Spinks
Rd 14 - 10-9, Holmes
Rd 15 - 10-9, Spinks

145-140, Spinks

 

Michael Dokes vs. Mike Weaver II

Felt Weaver deserved this when I first saw it way back when. Didn't score it back then, but was running a tally in my head. Anyways, here we go.

Round 1: 10-9 Dokes
Round 2: 10-9 Weaver
Round 3: 10-9 Dokes
Round 4: 10-9 Weaver
Round 5: 10-9 Dokes
Round 6: 10-10 Even
Round 7: 10-9 Weaver
Round 8: 10-9 Weaver
Round 9: 10-9 Weaver
Round 10: 10-9 Weaver
Round 11: 10-9 Dokes
Round 12: 10-9 Weaver
Round 13: 10-10 Even
Round 14: 10-9 Weaver
Round 15: 10-9 Weaver

Total: 146-141 Weaver

Obviously I still feel Weaver deserved it, but I will say that last five rounds became very sloppy and it's up to the one scoring on whether they see it for the harder puncher or one scoring with a bit more frequency.

 

Erik Morales - Marco Antonio Barrera I

Rd 1 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 2 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 3 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 4 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 5 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 6 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 7 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 8 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 9 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 10 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 11 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 12 - 10-8, Barrera

114-113, Barrera


Erik Morales - Marco Antonio Barrera II

Rd 1 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 2 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 3 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 4 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 5 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 6 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 7 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 8 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 9 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 10 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 11 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 12 - 10-9, Barrera

116-112, Morales


Erik Morales - Marco Antonio Barrera III

Rd 1 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 2 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 3 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 4 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 5 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 6 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 7 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 8 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 9 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 10 - 10-9, Barrera
Rd 11 - 10-9, Morales
Rd 12 - 10-9, Morales

114-114, Draw

 

Chris Byrd - Fres Oquendo (Highway robbery)

Rd 1 - 10-9, Byrd
Rd 2 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 3 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 4 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 5 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 6 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 7 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 8 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 9 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 10 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 11 - 10-9, Oquendo
Rd 12 - 10-9, Oquendo

119-109, Oquendo

 

Scored a lot recently.


Yamaguchi Falcao - Morgan Fitch

Rd 1 - 10-9, Fitch
Rd 2 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 3 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 4 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 5 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 6 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 7 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 8 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 9 - 10-9, Falcao
Rd 10 - 10-9, Falcao

99-91, Falcao


Rocky Fielding - John Ryder

Rd 1 - 10-9, Fielding
Rd 2 - 10-9, Fielding
Rd 3 - 10-9, Fielding
Rd 4 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 5 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 6 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 7 - 10-9, Fielding
Rd 8 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 9 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 10 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 11 - 10-9, Ryder
Rd 12 - 10-9, Ryder

116-112, Ryder

 

Amir Khan - Willie Limond

Rd 1 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 2 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 3 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 4 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 5 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 6 - 10-8, Limond
Rd 7 - 10-8, Khan
Rd 8 - 10-9, Khan

78-72, Khan at the time of stoppage


Amir Khan - Paulie Malignaggi

Rd 1 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 2 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 3 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 4 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 5 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 6 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 7 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 8 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 9 - 10-9, Khan
Rd 10 - 10-9, Khan

99-91, Khan at the time of stoppage


Miguel Cotto - Paulie Malignaggi

Rd 1 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 2 - 10-8, Cotto
Rd 3 - 10-9, Cotto
Rd 4 - 10-9, Cotto
Rd 5 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 6 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 7 - 10-9, Cotto
Rd 8 - 10-9, Cotto
Rd 9 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 10 - 10-9, Malignaggi
Rd 11 - 10-9, Cotto
Rd 12 - 10-9, Cotto

115-112, Cotto

 

Javier Fortuna - Jason Sosa

Rd 1 - 10-9, Sosa
Rd 2 - 10-9, Fortuna
Rd 3 - 10-9, Fortuna
Rd 4 - 10-9, Fortuna
Rd 5 - 10-8, Fortuna
Rd 6 - 10-9, Fortuna
Rd 7 - 10-9, Sosa
Rd 8 - 10-9, Sosa
Rd 9 - 10-9, Fortuna
Rd 10 - 10-7, Sosa

94-93, Fortuna at the time of stoppage


Hank Lundy - John Molina

Rd 1 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 2 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 3 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 4 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 5 - 10-9, Molina
Rd 6 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 7 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 8 - 10-8, Molina
Rd 9 - 10-9, Lundy
Rd 10 - 10-9, Lundy

97-92, Lundy at the time of stoppage

 

I remember seeing that one. I think they were showing the official scoring between rounds. I don't think it had been done before. Might of been after every three rds.

 

Al, the only time I had seen that done before was the world title fight between Jose Napoles and Clyde Gray. It becomes redundant when you pretty much know who will win down to the last few rounds, other than enjoying it of course if its a good fight.

 

Manny Pacquiao - Jeff Horn

Rd 1 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 2 - 10-9, Pacquiao
Rd 3 - 10-9, Pacquiao
Rd 4 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 5 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 6 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 7 - 10-9, Pacquiao
Rd 8 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 9 - 10-9, Pacquiao
Rd 10 - 10-9, Horn
Rd 11 - 10-9, Pacquiao
Rd 12 - 10-9, Pacquiao

114-114, Draw

 

Toney-Jirov. I didn't score it but what a amazing fight. Toney was so economical it was ridiculous

 

I had it 7 - 5 for Pac (same as yours but with round 12 to Pac).

6-6 is reasonable, maybe even 5-7 at a stretch.

I was a bit annoyed that the ref didn't warn Horn about careless control of his head, the constant armlocks and headlocks, and the hitting while holding and on the breaks.

All that said, before this fight, I would have bet on Pac over anybody at 140 or 147. Now, I doubt if he'd beat Thurman, Spence or Crawford.

He's slipped quite a bit.

The Pac of Cotto or even the Pac of Mosley would have had Horn out of there in a few rounds, even in the face of rough/dirty play. At 38, his time might have run out.


Did you watch Ward-Kovalev 2 ?

How did you have it at the time of stoppage, and what did you think of the stoppage?