In Their First 10 Pro Fights, Who's Been More Impressive? Vasyl or Floyd?

Stop it! No one here is suggesting anything like that. That would be like comparing PBF's pro career to Loma's.

 

What an .....

F crackhead, the conversation is over.

 

Chavez Sr defended the WBC Super Featherweight title a total of nine times, he beat several former and future champions, top contenders. He may lack quality wins at this weight but so did Hernandez.

Azumah Nelson was 39 years old when he fought Hernandez and he lost to a mediocre Leija before (and after) that. Nelson was only prime in your imaginary world.

Plus I could name other fighters who arguably rank higher than Hernandez at 130. Alfredo Escalera or Flash Elorde. Even Brian Mitchell could be mentioned who defended his title 12 times. Hernandez is no way top 5. You say he is the ATG @130? Do you factor in h2h ability? Obviously not. So that is a dumb statement

 

Don't mind that guy: he has an obvious anti-Loma agenda, it's having a seriously deleterious effect on any rational thought processes might have, and he's getting called out on it left and right.

True, there wasn't a Super Feather division at the time the likes of Griffo, Canzi, Pep, Saddler, Armstrong, Attell and Dixon were around; but, the last time I checked, 126 was within the 130 limit. Ergo, those Featherweights (and even some of the smaller Lightweights from before Super Feather was a thing) can be considered if they were weighing in at less than 130 for their fights (on same-day weigh-ins for most of the guys Serge listed, let's not forget).

Please tell me if my sums are wrong on this one, Serge ... because I'd hate to come off as that guy with an agenda. Truly, I would.

 

Which we kinda sorta are: we're comparing the first ten fights of each guy's professional ledger. Didn't you read the thread title before posting?

 

"Yeeeeeeeaaaaaah! We just gettin' started, baby!!!"

This content is protected

(To be honest, I love the way he says "yeeeeeeeaaaahh!!!" and says it over and over. I genuinely Lol'd at this video.)

 

Maybe Chacal also thinks Rogondeaux -- who is at best a small Featherweight -- would school every one of the people you listed in hypothetical dream matches over 15 rounds. And then school a prime Lightweight Duran over 15.

 

but you stipulated professional resume, thats what the OP has stuck by.

Its YOU changing the rules, your own ones.