The winners of these two fights

I would ask everyone to watch just the first two rounds of each of these fights. And honestly let me know what you think. I don't mind either way. I am interested in what people think after viewing these two rounds of both fights. Both in the same New York ring. Frazier in his last important win versus Lewis trained by Manny Steward.

This content is protected

This content is protected

 

The other thread started three days ago, I missed it and it seems to have petered out before I could contribute.

I'm happy to accept the result of the other poll. That one is rather too general in its approach and there is no guarantee voters are even watching fights before deciding.

my poll specifically asks voters to watch two rounds of two fights before voting. So what do you think?? Are you going to vote?

I'm happy to View rounds and vote on anybody else's selected fights to decide a winner.

 

it is not the worst part of Lewis! It’s fairest to compare two points fights. Lewis was great against mercer. It was a great, competitive fight that he won. Prime Lewis! If I picked the Tucker fight you would say he was not as good without Steward. If I picked the Mavrovic fight you would say it was an off night. If I picked the Holyfield fight you would have still found something wrong. Mercer is the best example where Lewis looked good in a competitive fight.

As for Frazier he had a tiny prime. Was he prime against Bonavena the first time? I don’t think so. He was prime by the second one so I suppose you could switch it for that fight but I can’t find full rounds on YouTube to make the same comparison. But if you can find it put it up.

 

Are you disagreeing with my points or not?

Do you think Tucker, Holyfeild, Bilups or Mavrovic would be a better showcase of Lewis in a points fight?

Do you think Machen, Bugner or Bonavena would be a better showcase of Frazier in a points fight?

I find it rather hollow that you strike accusations about my credibility and opinion without being able to answer if you agree or not.

 

Only glaringly obvious thing here is that you cannot Pick Lewis over Frazier on those performances.

McGrain even said Frazier would always look more coordinated than Lewis because he was. If this is the bit that you think must be "glaringly obvious" then go and tell me why the less coordinated Lewis can use performances against even less coordinated individuals against Frazier at his best and win. But you don't to this. I don't know why. Instead I get this claptrap about credibility and dishonesty.