Which perfomance vs Genaro Hernandez was better: Oscar or Floyd

Floyd. It was the correct weightclass.

 

Oscar De La Hoya took his soul. Made the warrior quit.

 

Floyd by far. This isn't a debate, it's a Floyd-hating troll thread. Oscar and Genaro boxed on even terms, Genaro had Oscar confused, Oscar was unsure how to integrate defence to attack, it was only when he was able to land with power that Oscar took over. While Floyd's speed gap won him every minute. When Floyd attacked with blazing combos Hernandez couldn't respond at all, when Hernandez tried to lead Floyd easily landed split-second counters. We really saw the best of PBF's offense against Hernandez, as he was able to land with brutal accuracy inside of Hernandez's length. Might well have been Floyd's most brilliant performance. Of course Floyd beat him at his best weight too.

 

Well, key distinction: Oscar and Hernandez didn't overall fight on even terms but they did 'box' on even terms. It took Oscar asserting his power to gain the upper hand. Oscar clearly won the 2nd to 6th, but Hernandez had moments in all those rounds, not just the 1st that he won. Hernandez had no success at all against Mayweather. We're comparing which of two dominant wins was more dominant. And because Floyd landed so much more and Oscar showed physical and tactical limitations Floyd didn't it should be clear that Floyd's performance was better.

 

Floyd beat chicanito straight up at chicanitos weight.
Dlh was supposed to fight chicanito at 130.
They postponed
Moved up and made chicanito come up
Also
Shane Mosley fractured chicanitos nose in 3 places before the fight.

 

FLOYD Def Oscar.