Do you respect Andre Ward and think he should be considered as an ATG?

I'd say he's a top 30 ATG at SMW and a top 100 ATG p40

 

its too early, becos he will be back to show everyone whether he is or not.

 

He is at home juicing up good and will come back and cherry pick a CW title after Usyk, Gassiev and Bredis move up.

 

Top 30? His win over Froch puts him at top 10.

 

Kov's jab is a serious serious weapon when on point and his long range is A Grade..He could box with the best of them

 

I agree. Main lining his way up to Cruiser

 

Respect, Yes. ATG? Maybe in a certain weight class but not on the over all list. Very good resume, but the stay at home antics and some dirty tactics sorta tarnishes it.

 

He was one of the very best to come along over the last 20 years.

Calzaghe will arguably be the rated the best SMW because of how long he was there defending titles but on sheer technical skill he wasn't on the same level as Ward and would have been deconstructed by him if they ever fought imo.

 

I don't see your point.

 

Don't agree with all of his career business moves. He should be several million dollars richer than he is, but I definitely respect him. He was one of the best 168 pounders ever, and moved up to 175, and fought a solid contender in Barrera, then fought a straight killer twice, unlike another undefeated 168 pounder, who moved up, fought two old men, then ducked Dawson like a coward, so he could ride the White Rhino into retirement.

 

Hof, but not top 100 for me. He is an ATG in a 168 context if we only rate the people who've fought there since its official inception.

 

Maybe he’s talking about since the inception of 168, in which case top 10 is underrating him pretty badly.

 

I have to respect him but I don't like him.

Personally, not an all time great but he will be regarded as the best SMW by many.

 

Did you put an extra zero on that 3, or did you really mean 30 ?

 

Do you disagree with me?