Why wasn't Calzaghe given more credit for his wins against RJJ and Hopkins?

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by OpinionOfACasual, Apr 15, 2018.


  1. HerolGee

    HerolGee Loyal Member banned Full Member

    41,974
    4,026
    Sep 22, 2010
    the point that, calzaghethecoward guy predates my use of youtube and ESB by several years, almost a decade, should be clue enough for you to shut up by now.


    But no, you couldnt let yourself look just merely stupid. You went for the Nobhed prize for stupidity by pretending you are still right.
     
  2. HerolGee

    HerolGee Loyal Member banned Full Member

    41,974
    4,026
    Sep 22, 2010
    yes, we do, as long as you figure in bhops age too.


    you cant have it both ways - though i note its not you asking for it both ways.
     
  3. Ph33rknot

    Ph33rknot Live as if you were to die tomorrow Full Member

    22,210
    21,944
    Mar 5, 2012
    If b hop had stopped there I would agree but he's been a top fighter till jr knocked him through the ropes
     
  4. HerolGee

    HerolGee Loyal Member banned Full Member

    41,974
    4,026
    Sep 22, 2010
    he'd been world, yes, but wasnt elite, as in "small handful who can beat all the others except other elites"
     
  5. OpinionOfACasual

    OpinionOfACasual Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,111
    3,981
    May 3, 2017
    At the end of the day you can argue that 'x,y or z' would win had they been 'prime'.


    An end of career Calzaghe fought, and beat, Hopkins and RRJ.
     
  6. Ph33rknot

    Ph33rknot Live as if you were to die tomorrow Full Member

    22,210
    21,944
    Mar 5, 2012
    who beat him
     
  7. OpinionOfACasual

    OpinionOfACasual Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,111
    3,981
    May 3, 2017
    Given Prime Calzaghe's style, do Prime RJJ and Prime Hopkins have to knock him out to beat him?
     
  8. HerolGee

    HerolGee Loyal Member banned Full Member

    41,974
    4,026
    Sep 22, 2010
    calzaghe dawson kov simith
     
  9. Ph33rknot

    Ph33rknot Live as if you were to die tomorrow Full Member

    22,210
    21,944
    Mar 5, 2012
    beside smith all top guys
     
  10. HerolGee

    HerolGee Loyal Member banned Full Member

    41,974
    4,026
    Sep 22, 2010
    kov was elite for sure. Dawson... i dunno. I'd say maybe at some point, if being generous, but he lost his way and his chance. Calzaghe, again, questions over being elite, when the only elite he beat was injured kessler. Hopkins was getting beaten soundly by elites in his 40s, and matched by worlders too. Its a bit much to call hopkins an elite in his 40s. no man ever has been....but for some reason he is becos it gives calzaghe a better win... na, backwards reasoning.
     
  11. _Frankly

    _Frankly Bivolian! banned Full Member

    360
    306
    Mar 17, 2018
    Page 13 :lol:

    Who was 30 & who was 43? Waiting...
     
  12. _Frankly

    _Frankly Bivolian! banned Full Member

    360
    306
    Mar 17, 2018
    Is that youtuber really him? :lol:
     
  13. Loudon

    Loudon Loyal Member Full Member

    40,556
    9,825
    Mar 7, 2012
    Of course not.

    You saw the Hopkins fight. A younger version wouldn't have had to have resorted to those kind of antics in order to have gained much needed breaks.

    Regarding an earlier fight with Roy, Joe would never have had the confidence to have taken that fight. That should be obvious to anybody who followed his career. But for the sake of the debate, I've got to assume that if he had've have done, he'd have been extremely cautious. It could have been a very dull fight with both guys feinting a lot and not wanting to commit fully. So my guess would have been Roy on points, unless Joe had have really pushed him hard and unloaded huge volume on him. At which point, they'd have ended up in a shootout. And there'd only have been one winner there. Roy was faster, more powerful, more accurate and harder to hit.
     
  14. Loudon

    Loudon Loyal Member Full Member

    40,556
    9,825
    Mar 7, 2012
    We all know about Byrd, but Compubox doesn't allow for technique, accuracy and ring generalship etc. They just score punches that have been thrown.

    We all know that Joe outlanded Bernard. Joe outlanded everyone. But many of his shots were ineffective, where he concentrated more on volume rather than accuracy. You can't win rounds just on out landing your opponent.
     
  15. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    78,038
    126,629
    Jul 21, 2009
    Carl Froch

    'Froch was left shattered when Jones career ended in shame as a drugs cheat. The Brit said: I was very, very annoyed. I put him on a pedestal. Unbeaten, a super-middleweight moving up to heavyweight and winning world titles.

    Pound of pound the best at the time, no one could hit him, he could punch, he could box, he could do everything and usually did in the ring.

    He hardly ever lost a round and then to find out he was cheating on drugs was quite devastating because I was a massive fan.

    You look back and you think was he that good or was he given an extra boost by something else?

    Were drugs giving him thee edge on his way to the top? Was it giving him the edge in hand speed, was it meaning he could go 12 rounds easy?

    Some of his fights were close late on. The guys he was fighting were looking tired and he was still looking sharp was that down to drugs?

    If he was still sharp because he was cheating, then that is unfair because you never know he might have come unstuck in those final two or three rounds.'

    Clinton Woods

    'Former IBF light heavyweight champion Clinton Woods says he’s not surprised that former opponent Antonio Tarver and other prominent American boxers are testing dirty. “I fought in America three times and the testing situation was always joke,” Woods told the Sheffield Star. “In three fights, I had one little test and was told it was only for marijuana. It’s always annoyed me how rife American boxing is with drugs and steroids, but at least they are cracking down on it now and people are being caught. The trouble is that people there will only get fined pocket money.”

    ''Me and Roy Jones didn't even get drug tested after the fight''

    "When it comes to taking drugs there is no excuse, none whatsoever"

    Woods continued with "I remember when I was boxing if I had a cold I used to go to the doctors and see if there was something that I could take because I knew that there were things I couldnt take; boxers know"

    Joe Calzaghe

    "I would hate to fight a cheat and I don't believe in cheating in any sport. I'm not calling him a cheat and I don't know what was taken or what happened," Calzaghe told The People. "I have to remember to take my vitamin C every morning and I believe in a fair fight."

    He says that even if his opponent, Jones or otherwise, took an illegal steroid, he would still beat them.

    "In athletics, a cheat gets disqualified, but in boxing if you get your ass kicked and then he's found to be a cheat, it doesn't matter because you can't reverse the decision and you've still had your ass kicked.

    ''In athletics drug cheats get banned automatically for two years, and if steroids can make athletes run faster, they can surely help a boxer to hit harder and to hit for longer and this will enable them to inflict more punishment, which I think is repulsive. During our pre-fight medicals we get tested for drugs and it's never crossed my mind to take anything performance-enhancing. I don't have a big pot of pills that I dip into all hours of the day. In fact, I have a job just to remind myself to take vitamins.

    ''I would be angry if someone I fought took something that gave him an unfair advantage because this is a dangerous sport, it's not like running. In athletics it now seems almost part of the culture, just like cycling, and the who idea is to stay one step ahead of testing. I sat alongside Justin Gatlin, at the time the reigning Olympic 100m champion, on the BBC's Question of Sport about a year ago and spoke to him afterwards. We talked about the Jeff Lacy fight because he's from Florida as well and he seemed like a really nice guy and I was genuinely shocked and disappointed when he failed a drugs test last summer. Whenever I watch athletics or cycling now I have my suspicions. Some get caught and some don't but I like to think that fighters are clean. Boxing's a warrior sport and, to me, there have always been values that go along with that.

    ''It's cheating there's no other word for it.''

    Montell Griffin

    ''Roy is not close to being the hardest puncher to ever hit me. But he was so fast that his speed was power. And you know, it's out there now, so it ain't no big secret, but he tested positive for steroids. People always questioned it, but then he tested positive and failed a test and it made me think he was on steroids for all of those fights''

    ''Roy Jones is a great fighter—one of the greatest fighters ever, but like I said, when I found out he failed the steroid test I just lost a lot of respect for him because I just thought he was on steroids when he beat me so that’s the only way I can look at it.”

    So when I took the knee, I pulled back, went down on my knee, and looked at up at the referee to start his count. By the time I looked up, the man hit me. He hit me the first time and it caught me off guard and then he loaded up and hit me the second time and at that point I could hear everything that was going on but it was like my body was paralyzed. I couldn’t move, I couldn’t do anything, I was trying to get up but I couldn’t move and I heard the referee counting and I was like, ‘Man, I can’t believe this! They’re going to count me out on this dirty punch.’ When I got up, came to, and got my faculties together I heard my brother say to Larry to disqualify Roy. Roy came over and apologized to me on like three occasions, said he was sorry. As we found out later on in his career that he failed steroid tests so I just feel that he was having roid rage. He was frustrated from what I was doing to him, he caught roid rage, he was frustrated so he hit me.''

    ''Like I said, when he failed the steroid test it kind of hurt me because of course me feeling like I was cheated, and because I looked up to this guy. Knowing that he cheated, it kind of took a little away from him.''

    Frank (British boxing promoter, surname is a place where rabbits live beginning with the letter W and ending in N. A ginger man if that helps)

    ''I knew Jones was messing around with steroids. "It all came out into the public and since he's stopped using he's not looked the same fighter. ''

    Roid Jones

    Former four division champion Roy Jones Jr. is wondering whether or not Antonio Tarver was on steroids in their 2004 rematch - where Tarver, on a single punch, stopped Jones in the second round and Roy was never the same boxer after that contest. On June 22, ***** broke the news that Tarver tested positive for drostanolone, an anabolic steroid. The failed test took place prior to Tarver's twelve round draw against Lateef Kayode on June 2 in California. Jones says it is "very possible" that Tarver was using steroids for their fight.

    Since the positive test result, several of Tarver's past opponents like Danny Green and Clinton Woods have been come in the press with similar questions.

    "You can call it a lucky punch but he did have to throw it. You can call it lucky or unlucky. The only problem I got is now that he's tested positive for steroids, it's very possible that he was on steroids when it happened. Other than that, it was a good punch, a clean punch - so I just can't go off that it was a lucky punch. But if he was on steroids, then it makes me understand on how he was able to stand there and why he was so confident to throw it, because he knows he's on steroids.