Bert Gilroy or Primo Carnera, pound for pound ?

Who was greater in a pound for pound sense ?

 

There was a lunatic on here who sincerely believed Gilroy was a world class fighter who was the victim of a conspiracy that kept him away from the world title, he absurdly overated Gilroy as much as certain posters do Carnera.
Neither name should ever be anywhere near the adjective GREAT!

 

Gilroy beat many forgotten greats.

"They" didn't want him!

 

Bloke was always angry if nobody excepted that gilroy was a truly great fighter

 

Please name these greats.lol

 

Oh come on, there's Ginger Sadd for starters!

I know it's true because Gilroy's grandson told me.

 

I miss those debates you had with the guy. Most amusing.