He was spot on with the Sharp card, maybe a little generous, and way off with the Catterall-Davies card.
Sharp did win the fight, but it was much much more closer than giving Woodstock only 1 round... Catterall simply did not win that fight, if anything Davies won it.
Many close but clear rounds in Archie's favor, he consistently landed the cleaner harder shots. I totally agree on your second point though.