who's a more dangerous opponent Charlo, Andrade?

Definitely looks like Charlo.

 

Watch Andrade vs culkay
Andrade is a bum. Ggg, canelo, Charlo, bjs, lemieux, Jacob's, murata and devrychenko murder him with ease

 

Charlo hands down. Andrade isn't durable enough.

 

Another vote for Charlo.

 

He deserves a lot of credit facing either of those young hungry lions.

 

I would say Charlo. Andrade is probably more talented, but just seems to lack a bit of the ruthless mentality at the very top level. Whereas Charlo has that eye-of-the-tiger sort of attitude.

It would be a good fight though.

 

Both beat Canelo that's why he moved up to 168

 

I think Andrade is a worse match-up for Canelo.

 

Charlo can be out boxed and power shots can be nullified. Andrade is harder to catch clean and out-box.

Andrade is more dangerous and harder to beat

 

And charlo has shown you as "durable" ?? come on get a grip. Andrade is a nightmare to box against.

If Bo-Mack, Crawford, Porter, Thurman, Ward all say the most talented guy in MW is Andrade they cant all be wrong.

 

Probably Charlo, but I'd need to see him fight a real middleweight contender before knowing for sure how good he is.

He's been very cautiously matched, it's time for him to step up and face a good opponent.

 

Charo is the interim which is really just modern term for being a top contender.

Cant say that about Andrade.

 

His very close calls over the years have painted a different picture though.

 

But can you see Andrade beating Canelo so clearly that the judges actually give him the win? Andrade would have to get a knockdown in each round for 12 rounds, minus bogus deducted points from Andrade, and still win each round without the knockdowns?... I feel it is close to impossible to win a decision against Canelo.

Canelo will not lose another match again until he get's knocked out clean.

Please don't misunderstand me, Canelo is a high level world class fight who will end up a multi-weight champion, p4p king with great wins and most likely go down as an top 50 AGT or better. With that said, everything is always stacked in his favour, anything that can go either way will always go to him, he will always get everything slightly better than his opponent; whether specifically when referees break fighters apart or ring size or gloves or catch-weights or re-hydration clauses and so forth.