Could Roy Jones have done as well vs Louis as Schmeling did in their 1st bout?

He could maybe do as well as Schmeling in the second bout.

 

Mark Ant, I enjoy some of your threads. But sometimes I feel that you don't need to always start new ones. You could just add to the discussion on the previous thread.
I'm sorry if my comment appears rude. It's certainly not my intention. It's just that recently, your constant threads are overtaking the front page. It doesn't leave room for others.
Again, I apologize if it's bad manners. Thanks

 

Roy destroys Louis, smdh. Who the hell has Louis beaten? Bill Conn, Max Bear, Peter Carnera WHO aghhh... doesnt even compare to Roy. Even Thomas Tate would have kilt Louis...

Roy = ATG with superflous abilities and member of Body Head Bangerz
Louis = ...huh? Is he even in a band

 

What's the betting your polite request for him to STFU gets ignored?

 

A long time ago....

 

So if you already think you know the answer and most people think similar, and it was already in another thread to discuss why do we need a separate thread devoted to something in a parallel thread?

No I don’t think he would beat Louis like Schmeling did....no I do not think he could win...I do think if he fough conservative he could potentially go the distance, but more than likely Louis catches him and stops him at some point

 

Haha, love the angry guy bit.
You would love me at work when things aren't going well.

 

You have better eyes than me! I have been here for 10+ years and few if any overrate Carnera and only the truest of modern is better vastly underrate Schmeling? But whatever floats your boat bro! Have a great day

 

Who overrated Roy at HW? I am not as high as some are on him...but you seem his largest detractor, by quite some margin....and I don’t even like him. But most don’t rate him at HW at all let alone overrate, outside of,...ah nevrrmind