How many losses should Floyd Mayweather really have? (Poll)

Probably only 1, to Castillo, but I give him another loss to Maidana because , well just because.

 

Castillo 1. Maidana fight was close, but I remember thinking it was a draw or Floyd edged it

 

Japanese critics has been saying 1 loss to Castillo and 1 Draw with Pac.

 

will you guys answer this question honestly ??

Does anyone honestly believe Joe Cortez would have counted out Floyd had Ortiz cowardly cold coked Floyd the way Floyd did him ?????

 

No. Ortiz would have been DQed and banned for a year

 

Maybe the first Castillo fight. Maidana 1 could have been a draw. No clue why people insist he lost the Oscar fight. Guy tired out in the last 4 rounds like he always did.

 

JLC 1, that's about it really

 

JLC 1 I thought Floyd lost a very close fight.

I don't think OLDH or Maidana won.

 

Just Castillo I.

Could argue an ND for Pacquiao though as he did get caught using Illegal IVs and it was brushed under the carpet. Actual fight, he won that though.

Had him beat Maidana 7-5
Had him beat Oscar 9-3

 

Floyd was out pointed in Castillo I and Pacquiao. Probably a draw against old ODLH. Then there are the ducks. Williams would have outpointed him. Margo would not have been hurt and would have posed problems. Prime Pac would have beaten him. Would have had problems at 140 with Tszyu and Cotto.

 

C

Maidana was a very close fight, Castillo wasn't he outlanded Floyd 2:1 or something like that.

 

1 for me, but his record should be 47-1-1-1

Loss to Castillo 1
Draw with Maidana 1
NC vs Pac

 

We've been over this before...

NC Manfredy
UD Castillo I
DRAW Castillo II
DQ Gatti
DQ Judah
SD Oscar
DQ Hatton
TKO2 Mosley
DQ Ortiz
DRAW Cotto
UD Maidana
KO3 Maidana II
TKO4 Pacquiao

37-10-2-1, with 3 stoppage defeats

 

Fights are scored by rounds, not punch stats. If you understand how boxing fights are scored you'd know that.

 

Castillo, DLH.

Maidana won the event.