Your most over rated fighters H2H?

Cotto really might be the most overrated. I think he gets beaten soundly by almost every ATG at 140 or 147 including all his countrymen(Benitez Trinidad Rosario Camacho, heck I think Wilfredo Rivera and Danny Garcia might even be a 50/50 fights for Cotto

 

??? Out of curiosity who has picked Cotto to beat some greats, or has there ever been a consensus on him beating some greats?

 

It's not out of the question, it's just highly unlikely.

 

H2H these fighters get overrated when talking mythical match ups:

SRR
Ali
Duran
SRL
Monzon
Ricardo Lopez
Salvador Sanchez

Today I think people really overrate Mayweather and Lomachenko's abilities.

 

Just about every ATG heavyweight under 210lbs.

 

Can't believe you didn't mention Bazooka.

 

I know I'm in the minority, but I believe Joe Louis gets overrated h2h. What I mean by that is, if you have him in your top 10 h2h, he's not overrated. If you have him top 3, I believe he's being overrated.

 

Lol have I tipped my hand? I guess if I was making a list of 5 I could add him and Zarate

 

I respectfully disagree here 100%
Your top list except for Lopez who I haven't watched enough of are H2H monsters

 

Gotta agree to be honest. Although Marciano and Dempsey both deserve mentions

 

You should have been on this forum 10 years ago there was a bunch of Dempsey advocates. Very few anymore. To me he is outside of the top 10 and while there may be some Dempsey advocates they are not a vocal majority. I would say he has tapered off at least as far as this forum goes.

Marciano is a tough one. There is a small segment that overrates him but they are matched in numbers vociferousness and animosity by a vocal core of detractors and underrated....gotta say in honesty that the detractors and hate filled rants about him are my least favorite posts on this forum. I rate him at 10 not sure if that makes me in the under or over rating crowd?

 

I have heard a ton of people call him P4P a top 3 Puerto Rican of all time and they site H2H as one of the reasons

 

I've got Marciano a little lower than 10 maybe 11/12 (I haven't got an actual heavyweight list however) but that's a good 5 places above Dempsey. I've seen how overrated he was in those threads whilst reading hyperthetical match ups.

 

Vitali!

 

Andre Ward is another one. I think people have him beating almost everyone at 168 except Roy and they have him beating a lot of guys at 175.

I think at 168 Collins, Hearns, and Toney beat him.

At 175 theres plenty who would be big favorites