Buddy McGirt vs...

Two loses, but performs respectably.

 

He loses both.

Great fighter tho.

 

both win a decision over him. I think he'd make it closer with Tito. These guys are just too tall with too great a reach. Buddy was good a counterpunching straight ahead guys, see his fight with Simon Brown. Both these guys were bigger than Brown and a little better defensively.

 

James mcgirt is an underrated fighter. Truly one of the great p4p forces of his time. I wouldn't pick him to best the two men in question but he'd give a galant effort against both and I wouldn't rule out an upset... He wasn't supposed to beat simon brown either..

 

Loses, but acquits himself better than expected. Go Buddy!

 

Again, loses to both but a solid guy nonetheless

 

I never thought he was that good. Taylor beat him easily. He was not taller than him.

 

Height and reach would play a factor against Trinidad and De la Hoya.

There is more than one way to skin a cat.

Taylor beat him to the punch with incredible handspeed.

Whitaker beat him with angles.