Ali was in a unique position to judge as he was the only person in the world who was on the receiving end of every punch that hit him. Are you suggesting that he might be wrong when he said Frazier and Shavers hit him harder than anyone else?? That would be quite something.
In the heat of many battles and then looking back over a long period of time to his career, he could well be mistaken.
I don't think it's a case of having to look back over his career. The hardest punch he receives will be such a significant moment that he'll be immediately aware of it for what it is, until it gets overtaken by someone hitting him even harder.
I think when you get hit like that, you feel it! You hear boxers describe what it feels like to get hard. Holmes did so about being hit by Shavers. It can also be judged by the effect it has on you.
Holmes was cracking the hell out of Ali in the last two rounds...though I do think he carried him to some extent. Once again I'm lost as to the round THAT Foreman uppercut landed (have to watch the fight again). Ali was clinching...he talked about it at length in his book. And yeah, George landed flush with that uppercut. Too flush.
Well, DavidC77 does have an interesting, practical idea there. So I guess Ali saying Shavers hit him hardest would make sense then, as it's hard to imagine him having been hit harder after that fight, a very late-career titular defense. The Shavers thing rings true for me. Ali's eyes were going pretty wild a few times in that fight, at one point it looked like he was getting knocked around the ring.
I sort of agree!! Just when you think about the myriad of punches Ali took in his career, it would probably be difficult for him to pick the actual hardest one out. But if he said it was Shavers, then it was Shavers!!
I just saw that video (it was a Phil Donahue type of show from I think the early 80s...maybe just before Holmes) a few weeks ago for the first time. The audience asked and Ali said it without hesitation "that would be Earnie Shavers". People here, including me, are very impressed by the rights of Lewis, Foreman, Liston, Louis, Wilder. They were all remarkable punchers. But none of them had that nuclear bomb. Nuh-uh.