Would you rate Canelo over Mayweather if he wins in November?

To answer the question the thread poses the answer is NO!!
If the fight is held at the correct weight of 175 limit ,which is the only way it would be legal, the weights of both fight night wont be more than 5 pounds apart.
The fight being held in Canelo's hometown haven Vegas has everyone saying all Canelo has to do is be standing at the final bell & he cannot lose. no need to hide that fact even the corrupt commission havent tried to hide it in the past.
In fact, with Clen & Floyd NEITHER of them come anywhere close to Manny Pacquaio as fighter of the Era & Fighter of the Decade. Both have too many dark clouds of suspicion of cheating, Ped's abuse& corruption in officiating which in my opinon has been BLATANT !! In fact I have no respect whatsoever for either .
Pacquaio's resume is head & shoulders above Clen & Floyd's In fact I rank GGG 's resume as better than both too. He should still be the undefeated World Middleweight Champion today & I'm far from alone in that opinion

 

I mean, Floyd schooled him so no chance.

 

Good post, except for calling me irrational LOL

I will admit I am bias. I think every single person and fan of boxing is biased in one way or another. I tend to be biased in favor of fighters I'm a fan or, and I'm a fan of fighters who posses certain elements I appreciate.

As far as being irrational, I completely disagree, and I think you're being irrational for viewing me this way. I've known you a long time, and I would like to make you a challenge, I'd like to challenge you to post at least 5 posts within the last five years that you deem irrational.

You see, I would never say something about anyone unless I had something to back it up, and I'm sure you are the same way.

 

I don't rate Canelo higher than Mayweather, but that's a flawed argument.

Antonio Margarito destroyed Sergio Martinez but we all rank Martinez higher.

 

Yeah you can obviously prove that by reading this thread

 

My thoughts exactly.

Change the name on the title to Pacquiao or Golovkin and this thread becomes a cesspool of feces with Pacterds or GGGoons yelling off the top of their lungs.

 

The initial knee jerk reaction to say "hell no" or "not even close" is understandable but the premise is not that far-fetched.

 

I'd consider his resume at that point greater than Mayweather's, but still not as good as Pacquiao's.

 

That is because Sergio Martinez improved and a lot people think it would have gone very differently if they fought again. Canelo is a good fighter and has probably improved too, but not enough. He was thoroughly bested with movement and pot shotting by a past it, smaller Floyd.

 

Yeah but neither was Canelo. Hey was 23, had stamina issues and weight drained.

 

Ah you reminded me of the catchweight. That changes things a bit.

 

Oooohhhh hark at you

 

If you want to stick up for a drugs cheat that’s upto you fella . I happen to think they are a disgrace but you obviously rate them .