British boxing robberies, suspect judging and ref watch compendium

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by pow, Nov 26, 2019.



  1. pow

    pow Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,502
    3,619
    Apr 26, 2014
    Rep a recent British boxing robbery, suspect ref or suspect cards and I will add it to the OP.



    • 03-12-2022 (Q) Dubois v Lerena TKO REFWATCH (Foster)
    • 26-11-2022 (M) Whyte v Franklin MD (Alexander) 115-115 (Langos) 116-112 (Molenda) 116-112
    • 26-02-2022 (B) Taylor v Catteral (Foster) 112-113 (IJL) 114-111 (Loughlin) 113-112
    • 25-09-2021 (M) Hatton v Martinez 58-57 (Mcdonnell)
    • 28-08-2021 (Q) Ennis-Brown v Maxwell UD (Gray) 113-116 (Latham) 114-115 (McDonnell) 113-116
    • 13-02-2021 (M) Barret v Martinez UD (Foster) 116-113 (Gray) 118-111 (Williams) 118-111
    • 12-12-2020 (M) Marku v Stewart D 76-76 (McDonnell)
    • 17-10-2020 (M) Riston v Vasquez UD 115-113 (Alexander) 113-116 (McDonnell) 117-111 (O'Connor)
    • 21-01-2020 (K) McKenna v Mimoune UD 97-93 (Coakley) 96-94 (McCann) 96-94 (McDonnell)
    • 19-12-2019 (M) Riakorphe v Massey UD REF WATCH (Edwards) 115-113 (Alexander) 115-113 (Foster) 117-111 (Williams)
    • 13-12-2019 (O) Sokolowski v Sandland 28-29 (Alexander) 28-29 (Foster) 28-29 (Sarginson)
    • 23-11-2019 (M) Smith v Ryder UD 116-112 (Rosa) 117-111 (O'Connor) 116-112 (Torres)
    • 16-11-2019 (K) McGregor v Farooq UD 114-113 (Edwards) 113-114 (Latham) 115-112 (Lyson)
    • 02-11-2019 (M) Crolla v Frank Urquaia MD 95-95 (Alexander) 97-93 (Foster) 98-92 (Gray)
    • 28-06-2019 (K) Davies v Vasquez UD 97-94 (IJL)
    • 01-06-2019 (M) Taylor v Persoon MD 96-94 (Nace) 96-94 (Poutraj) 95-95 (Trella)
    • 01-12-2018 (O) Wilder v Fury Draw SD 113-113 (Edwards) 115-111 (Rochin) 112-114 (Tapper)
    • 30-11-2018 (K) Benson v McKenna W 95-96 (Alexander)
    • 24-11-2018 (M) Yafai v Gonzalez UD 116-112 (Laine) 116-112 (Padilla) 117-111 (Quartorone)
    • 03-11-2018 (S) Parker v Williams SD 115-114 (Gray) 113-115 (IJL) 117-112 (Loughlin)
    • 24-05-2018 (O) Brubaker v Nurse UD 115-113 (Haefey) 116-112 (Israel) 116-112 (Lucas)
    • 31-03-2018 (M) Joshua v Parker UD REF WATCH (Quartarone)
    • 13-12-2017 (M) Benn v Peynaud PTS 57-54 (Williams)
    • 10-12-2017 (M) Whyte v Chisora SD 115-114 (Alexander) 115-113 (Foster) 114-115 (Gray)
    • 22-04-2017 (M) Murray v Rosado SD 119-109 (Jankowiak) 116-112 (Molenda) 114-114 (O'Connor)
    • 22-04-2017 (M) Fielding v Ryder SD 114-115 (Alexander) 116-113 (Foster) 115-114 (Williams)
    • 12-11-2016 (M) McDonnell v Solis UD 115-113 (Christodoulou) 117-111 (Hoyle) 116-112 (Vasquez)
    • 24-09-2016 (M) Ryder v Arnfield UD CARD WATCH 117-114 (O'Connor) 110-118 (Pineda) 114-115 (Williams)
    • 23-11-2013 (M) Froch v Groves TKO 9 REF WATCH (Foster)
    • 07-09-2013 (M) Burns v Beltran SD Draw 114-114 (Davies) 115-112 (Ortiz jr) 113-115 (Grootenbruel)
    • 27-04-2013 (O) Martinez v Murray UD 115-112 (DeLuca) 115-112 (Hidalgo) 115-112 (Rochin)
    • 07-07-2012 (M) Brook v Jones MD 115-113 (Barry) 116-113 (Gray) 114-114 (Kuechler)
    • 03-11-2011 (S) Helnius v Chisora SD 113-115 (Jankowiak) 115-113 (Palomo) 115-113 (Quartarone)
    • 09-09-2011 (Q) Cox v Sai UD 113-115 (Davies) 112-114 (IJL) 113-114 (McDonnell)
    • 25-06-2011 (O) Sturm v Macklin UD 113-115 (L.Martinez) 116-112 (J.Martinez) 116-112 (Ramirez Sr.)
    • 09-11-2009 (O) McDermott v Fury W 92-98 (O'Connor)
    • 07-04-2007 (Q) Calzaghe v Manfredo TKO 3 REF WATCH (O'Connor)
    • 02-12-2005 (O) Froch v Groenewald TKO 5 REF WATCH (Foster)
    • 13-12-2003 (S) Ottke v Reid UD 115-113 (Mancini) 117-112 (Marti) 115-113 (Martinez)
    M=Matchroom S=Sauerland Q=Queensbury K=MTK O=Other B=Boxxer​
     
    Last edited: Dec 5, 2022
  2. ryanm8655

    ryanm8655 Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,750
    2,824
    Oct 23, 2008
    Good idea, Wilder - Fury springs to mind as a fight involving a Brit but wasn’t promoted by a British promoter.

    Ryder - Fielding...

    Froch - Groves 1 (dodgy stoppage but was very suspect).
     
    pow likes this.
  3. Journey Man

    Journey Man Journeyman always. Full Member

    4,951
    2,121
    Aug 22, 2009
    (M) Whyte vs Chisora, Whyte wins SD 115-114 (Alexander), 115 - 113 (Foster) 114-115 (Gray.) Not sure if that's a robbery given the scorecards are close, as was the fight, though I remember most scoring it for Del Boy.
     
  4. ryuken87

    ryuken87 Active Member Full Member

    1,468
    876
    Mar 8, 2014
    Don't remember the scores but Murray - Rosado wasn't good.
     
    Journey Man and pow like this.
  5. Jurgen

    Jurgen Pay Per Pudding Advisor banned Full Member

    13,416
    19,415
    Sep 30, 2016
    7/9/13 Burns v Beltran in Glasgow - quite simply a one sided pasting over 12 rounds with Burns suffering a broken jaw in round 2.

    Credit to Burns and Billy Nelson for keeping going to the final bell but a draw was a sensational result given what happened in the ring.
     
  6. TonyHayers

    TonyHayers Well-Known Member banned Full Member

    2,863
    2,370
    Nov 1, 2018
    I genuinely think the Froch Groves I stoppage came about five seconds or so too early. But it was coming and Groves was a goner.

    Worst stoppage I’ve seen in a British ring in the last few decades both involve Enzo Maccarinelli. Ian John Lewis stooped him when there was absolutely nothing wrong with him, and then in Warren’s magnificent seven card (pretty sure he was fighting Alexander Frenkel) that Finnish ref let him go on when he was absolutely out of it.

    Some of the above aren’t robberies.
     
    hpsauce91 likes this.
  7. kojak

    kojak Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,907
    2,947
    Apr 22, 2012
    Ryder vs Arnfield. Ryder won it but another one with terrible cards.

    Two of the cards were 117-114 and 118-110 to Arnfield.
     
    pow, Twentyman and Tankatron like this.
  8. Mitch87

    Mitch87 Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,463
    5,319
    Jul 29, 2018
    Whyte vs Chisora first fight wasnt a robbery. I actually watched recently again and had Whyte winning even more comfortably than I remeber.
     
    TonyHayers likes this.
  9. Mitch87

    Mitch87 Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,463
    5,319
    Jul 29, 2018
    Ottke vs Reid is worst case of biased officiating I've ever seen.

    Fury vs McDermott & Ryder vs Smith were both very bad judging (Terry O' Connor!).
     
    Last edited: Nov 26, 2019
  10. Octolony shore

    Octolony shore Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,090
    2,165
    Sep 14, 2016
    Still can't believe fat arse O'connor had fury beating Mcdermott by six rounds, one of many from the greedy brown envelope taker.
     
    Scissors and Jurgen like this.
  11. TonyHayers

    TonyHayers Well-Known Member banned Full Member

    2,863
    2,370
    Nov 1, 2018
    Yeah. For me that’s a good example of a fight where the big favourite ends up squeaking home against an outsider. People always cry robbery in those but for me Whyte just about won it. Couldn’t argue with a draw to be fair.

    I actually thought the cards in the rematch (in favour of Chisora) were a lot worse.
     
  12. Jurgen

    Jurgen Pay Per Pudding Advisor banned Full Member

    13,416
    19,415
    Sep 30, 2016
    The Jock fight last week when an Asian Lad called Farooq got ripped wider than John Ryder
     
  13. Jurgen

    Jurgen Pay Per Pudding Advisor banned Full Member

    13,416
    19,415
    Sep 30, 2016
    That is the worst card ever produced - nothing will ever beat that one by Spud O'Connor
     
  14. Bridie mcmahon

    Bridie mcmahon Active Member banned Full Member

    1,213
    918
    Sep 10, 2015
    Davies v vasquez was bad.With davies admitting he lost post-fight.
     
    pow likes this.
  15. Octolony shore

    Octolony shore Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,090
    2,165
    Sep 14, 2016
    He also had Smith winning by six on Saturday, unbelievable really. I reckon he fills the card in beforehand and has a nap during the fight.
     
    lencoreastside, Smudge_ and Jurgen like this.