No boxer in history can beat a Prime Floyd Mayweather Jr. (at his weight class) Agree or not?

Is it something special that he can beat people his own size or smaller?

Guys like Joe Louis, Mike Tyson, Holyfield, Ali beat men who were several inches taller and weighed more than themselves.

 

This OP is a troll right???

A prime Duran savages Floyd at the lighter weights i just think Duran would be too powerful, too skillful on the inside. Floyd shoulder roll and pull counter aint going to work when the guy is on your chest. Floyd's a great fighter but he's best with some range to work with.
Duran all day. He might have 14 defeats but look who they were against. Hagler well above prime weight and many of those defeats came when he was past his best, this was a guy who fought everyone. Past his best a weight class or 3 above what he should be he still beat Iran Barkley that's how good he was. When has Floyd ever done that? Gone into a fight with everything stacked against....him he hasn't? Look at JMM dragged him up a couple of weights..
Hatton dragged him up a division (he beats Hatton at any weight but Hattons best years were at 140).

Hearns also beats Floyd elite level KO power, wicked jab and body punches. Floyd struggled with a past prime ODH who was able to pin him back with the jab - Hearns jab is up there with the best, he's the bigger man, more power good boxing brain. If Mossley can ring Floyds bell you bet Hearns is

Dissmissing Ray Robinson - dangerous man - a guy with 100+ fights with wins over names that still echo around now but he wouldn't give Floyd a fight?? Madness! A guy with more KO's than Floyd had fights??? It's al;ways hard to judge guys from vastly different era's but SRR would be in the fight and no mistake

Hagler if he cut to Floyds weight?? Are you on glue? Hagler was an elite level bad ass at middle he won't be draining down to Floyds weight.

As for your comments on Manny you could say the say about him -he was past his best to - the Pac that fought Cotto might have given him more problems although I think the size advantages and Floyds style would probably keep him our of harms way even against a prime Pac

 

Disagree firmly, because I don't believe there exists such a thing as an unbeatable fighter.

 

Have Floyd fight Duran Leonard and Hearns at their prime and see if he beats any let alone all

 

Leonard and hearns beat floyd

Idk about duran or robinson

Possibly paul williams as well

 

lol how can you say he beats Oscar everytime when he barely beat Oscar when he was bordering being washed up and was 8 years past his best and already lost a few times. In fact, Oscar was beating Floyd when they were both fresh. Even Emmanuel stewart who was loving on Floyd all fight was forced to admit around the 7th round if Floyd didn't pick it up he was going to lose the fight. And the only reason he started taking over the fight around the 9th was because Oscar started gassing. They asked him why he stopped throwing his jab since it was basically dictating the fight for Oscar and he sidestepped the question after. Its because once he started gassing it lost some zip and was hanging it out there just long enough for Floyd to throw his right hand counter over up. Floyd won that fight by 1-2 rounds. To think a prime Oscar who was notably faster, punches were more vicious, had better endurance and would never gas vs a smaller, less powerful fighter like Floyd. To think he could have won another 2-3 rounds in his prime or even KO Floyd is Ludacris. This was also the addict Oscar fighting too. You put Floyd vs that 97-2000 Oscar, Oscar would destroy him. Floyd has never faced anything remotely like that in his career.

 

Hearns was far better than Floyd his reach would make his straight right too hard for Floyd to counter from the shoulder roll and Tommy was far better a opening opponents up, plus he out-boxed Benitez Floyd never beat a prime fighter on Wilfredo`s level, Duran wa also better than Floyd offensively.

 

Hagler would be far too big for Floyd, he would have jabbed his head off with that long lead, Marvin was a killer.

 

I thought Floyd lost first time I saw it. I also believe Trinidad would beat Floyd. To think anything else than that the Fabulous 4 would beat Floyd is crazy talk.

 

He coulda fought a prime Pac, but he needed an extra edge. USada in his pocket to give him TUE post fight.

Ironic he was the one caught with illegal IVs when that was what derailed a fight with a prime pac.

And to answer your question, quite a few “could” have beat him, would they have, who knows.

Chavez could do a Castillo but better. Duran would swarm him. A past it ODLH took him to SD granted not at floyds best weight so a prime one coulda done better. SRL would be favoured based on floyds fight with Judah (fighting a fast slick technical boxer). Hearns would stop him.