Shannon Briggs vs Herbie Hide

Two big punchers but Briggs could take them better then Hide so I'm going with Briggs to finish this early. Thoughts?

 

Briggs would lay Hide out.

 

Hide was the better boxer, better mobility and speed. But Briggs was too durable and powerful for him, stopping the "better fighter" imho.
Thats were power*chin-level comes into play.
Same thing made Max Baer very successful fighting CWs.

 

I favor Briggs, but a Hide upset isn’t impossible

 

Briggs lands a shot from the blue and takes out Hide.

 

Tell the truth Fergy. You're picking Briggs because he's from Brownsville, aren't you?

 

I wouldn't rule out Hide.

 

Are we talking prime for prime or current day?

2020 Briggs turns 2020 Hide into McRib.

 

I pick Hide
Briggs lost all the important fights he had, he was lucky against Liakhovich, Briggs is a 3 rounds fighter and Hide can move well.

 

What? Hide never even beat a good fighter.

Briggs at least beat Liakovich, an old Mercer, and got a controversial draw against Botha/win over Foreman.

 

Briggs only beat Liakhovich.. old Mercer doesnt count, he lost with Foreman and draw with Botha
Hide beat Bentt.
Hide did not lose the same amount as briggs, in difficult fights briggs only won 1 of 8 or so,
Hide lost against elite fighters

 

Briggs would tan Herbie's Hide

 

Hide beat Bentt who KO'ed Morrison in 1, he aslo demolished old Tucker. Briggs had much more troubles against Mercer who was 8 years older than Hide's Tucker. 49 y.o. Foreman clearly beat Briggs and so did very average Botha. Briggs only real good win was a last-second KO over Liakhovich in a fight which he was losing handily. I think his resume isn't better that Hide's one but I'd probably slightly favor him against Hide since Herbie had really glass jaw

 

Stop

 

Any arguments?