Top 5 H2H MWs?

Very hard for me, Lach and Greg to narrow down. Will be the Classic topic on the podcast, looking forward to hearing opinions. Oh, and I'll probably be playing Devil's advocate here, not just questioning every single opinion people have.

 

Cheers for replying, just some points/queries.

Greb is a lock, no arguments from me there. Hagler is also crazy high, but I'm not sure how high. Who do think would turn the trick here? I'd pick Monzon, Greb and Hopkins but not too many others.

Hopkins may get you some flack, but I'm sympathetic here; I like him to beat both Monzon and Hagler. Who would you favour over him? And/or who would you favour him over?

Robinson ran hot and cold throughout his middleweight run, but in his absolute prime he was awesome. Although he was a tad small, and a combination of hittable, out-jabable and out-workable. How do you think he fairs against Greb, Jones, Hagler ect.

Did you consider Monzon, LaMotta or Fitzsimmons? Also, EZZARD. CHARLES.

 

Interesting choices, can I ask why?

Robinson and Monzon above Greb?

 

Same routine, first up: No Greb? Is that a lack of footage thing?

I'm liking the Hopkins > Monzon and Hagler thing again, but I'm not sure I'm inclined to completely agree. You got a rough list of who beats who, off the top of your head? Love the Steele mention, but I'm not sure I agree. I pondered him myself, but is he a lock over Greb and Fitzsimmons? If you're only going off guys who was can watch, how about LaMotta, Tiger, Jones ect.

I don't agree with Robinson at #1, but obviously it's arguable and I've seen you talk excessively about Robinson and the St. Valentine's Day massacre; certainly enough to know I'm out of my depth, so I'll agree to disagree.

 

I'm seeing a pattern here. Is this in order? If so, I'd love to know how you came about putting Hopkins at #1.