Fights in which people disagree on the winner

Every fight that goes the distance these days...

 

Interesting question. Ali - Norton III, maybe Ellis - Patterson.

 

Griffith vs Rodriguez ...all 4 fights

 

Griffith vs Tiger 1

 

Monzon vs Griffith 2

 

Duran vs Barkley was a split decision

 

Leonard vs hagler? I could not imagine a more clear victory

 

Really, I thought it was so close it could easily have been given either way.I gave it to Leonard but had no quarrel with those making Hagler the winner and many respected boxing people did.imo It was too close to call it a robbery whichever way it went.
I would in fact be very circumspect in putting faith in the ability of some one to judge a bout who saw this fight as producing a clear unarguable winner.

 

Leonard won this fight clearly, using the footwork and speed moving around and even when they traded leonard looked better cause his superior hand speed and he always had the last word

 

You are entitled to your opinion,and I am entitled to disagree with it and I do.
It seems I have company too!

• Dave Anderson of the New York Times: 114-114

• Associated Press: 117-112 Hagler

• Baltimore Sun: 7-5 in rounds Leonard

• Al Bernstein of ESPN: 115-113 Hagler

• Dave Bontempo of ESPN: 114-114

• Boston Globe: 117-111 Leonard

• Boston Herald 116-113 Leonard

• Chicago Sun-Times: 115-114 Hagler

• Chicago Tribune: 7-5 in rounds Hagler

• Nigel Collins of The Ring: 115-113 Leonard

• Howard Cosell: 117-112 Leonard

• Houston Chronicle: 115-114 Leonard

• Michael Katz: 117-112 Leonard

• Harold Lederman of HBO: 115-113 Leonard

• Phill Marder of The Ring: 114-114

• Larry Merchant of HBO: 114-114

• New York Daily News: 117-111 Leonard

• New York Post: 114-114

• Newsday: 115-114 Hagler

• Philadelphia Daily News: 116-112 Leonard

• Oakland Tribune: 117-112 Leonard

• Jeff Ryan of KO Magazine: 118-111 Leonard

• San Jose Mercury-News: 116-115 Hagler

• United Press International: 116-112 Leonard

• Washington Post: 114-114

 

DeLaHoya-Trinidad
Lewis-Mercer
Gatti-Patterson 1
Tapia-Ayala 2
Pacquiao-Marquez

 

Lewis v Mercer
Fenech v Nelson
Holmes v Spinks 2
Benn v Eubank 2
Lenard v Hearns 2
Mancini v Camacho
Zarate v Pintor
Parker v Hamsho 1
Young v Norton
GGG v Canelo 1+2
I know I disagree with these off the top of my head. I'm sure theres plenty more

 

Judging by another thread here, Berbick vs. Ali.

 

Snipes-Coetzee.